Category: Top 100

  • “Perhaps I Ought To Chalk It?”: The 9th Most-Broadcast BBC Programme Of All Time

    “Perhaps I Ought To Chalk It?”: The 9th Most-Broadcast BBC Programme Of All Time

    What’s got eight legs, 22 balls and would kill you if it fell on you from a tree?


    9: Snooker

    (Shown 4882 times, 1937-2021)

    All together now: “For those watching in black and white, the pink’s behind the blue…”. Except, Whisperin’ Ted’s infamous line actually came from Pot Black, which is a distinctly different proposition to the next ‘programme’ on the list.

    So: Snooker. Always a contender for the top ten, and perhaps a little surprising to see it as low as ninth.

    With the sport lacking a unifying ‘Match of the Day‘-style branding, actual tournament play went out under the title of, well, ‘Snooker’ (or variants thereof), taking it into this top ten position. And that’s because, well, there’s been rather a lot of it on the BBC over the years. More of it than you could shake Len Ganley at. And it goes back a lot further than one might expect.

    For a spectator sport where identifying colours such as yellow, green, brown, blue, pink and black is pretty darned integral, you’d reasonably expect it to only become a broadcasting event following the advent of colour television. Except, not only was it first broadcast long before BBC2 started pumping out colour programming, snooker was first beamed to the nation before television was a going concern. On Tuesday 10 December 1935, listeners to the London Regional Service were treated to fifteen minutes of commentary on a match-up between England’s Joe Davis, considered the world’s top player at the time, and Australian Horace Lindrum, then considered the globe’s secondmost snookersmith. As if to underline the challenge of describing the action to an audience who’d largely never seen a snooker table in their lives, the Radio Times printed one alongside that day’s radio listings.

    For those reading in black and white, etc etc. This would at least have saved Willie Smith spending fourteen minutes trying to explain the setup.

    How practical that miserly fifteen minutes may have proved is up for debate, of course. Snooker finals are hardly short affairs in this day and age – for example, the 2023 World Championship final between Luca Brecel and Mark Selby was a best of 35 frames. And that’s a brief clatter around a youth club table compared to this match, a prize match to settle a £100-per-man wager, based on two lots of 61 frames. The following day’s Daily Mirror reported that that day’s session had seen Lindrum come back from 10-5 down at the start of the afternoon’s play to draw level on ten frames all, with an aggregate points total of Davis’ 5,223 versus Lindrum’s 5,244.

    The report also included mention of the match’s status as broadcasting first, relating how commentator Willie Smith (himself a billiards champion who’d turned his hand to the increasingly lucrative snooker) told of missed sitters (causing “expressions of amazement from spectators”) during that inaugural summary. That match between the two would go on for several more days – at one point breaking so that cheques for £650 could be awarded to Chelsea footballers George Mills and Harold Miller before play continued – only to end with Joe Davis winning by 32 frames to 29, ending the series at one match apiece, and subsequently nullifying the bet. In short: a lot of snooker, then nobody won.

    I mean, I say “nobody won”.

    Of course, that fifteen-minute fix of audio green baize action would be all that radio listeners received from that particular match, but Willie Smith was back on the lip-mic the following February for the rematch. This time, a generous 25 minutes were given to the coverage, which was won (along with the £200 kitty) by Davis. Moreover, snooker had begun to thrill the nation. And put paid to any claim from DLT that he invented Snooker On The Radio.

    11 April 1936 saw live coverage from Dublin of a match between Seamus Fleming and W Lowe, as snooker began to grow in popularity in the Irish Free State, while the end of that month saw running commentary from the final of that year’s British Championship, where… Joe Davis beat Horace Lindrum. Again. Another sporting first occurred during sports roundup Saturday Contrast in December, with live coverage of Women’s World Snooker Champion Ruth Harrison as she took on Women’s World Billiards Champion Joyce Gardener, albeit in the discipline of billiards, with a ‘substantial prize’ on offer to the victor.

    By now, television was on the scene, and surely snooker was a prime sporting candidate for the new medium. Admittedly, visual coverage of the sport would lack the verbal colour of radio commentary, but it would be so much easier to see what was going on, and unlike with many sports, a single fixed camera could be employed to relay the action. And so, on 14 April 1937, snooker was introduced to the television audience for the first time, with an offering billed as An Exhibition of Play by Horace Lindrum and Willie Smith.

    Even more excitingly for readers of the Daily Telegraph on the morning of broadcast, there was the implication the event would include full orchestral accompaniment:

    Sadly, they were two unrelated broadcasts.

    Luckily that week’s Radio Times went into more detail. The article explained how, from the early 1930s, snooker had gone from a distraction adopted by billiards professionals once they’d got a bit bored with their day job, to a sport that had overtaken its sister game in popularity. Initially, the announcement that a session of billiards was to be followed by some frames of snooker would result in half the audience suddenly realising they’d left the gas on and would leave the exhibition hall.

    But, slowly but surely, billiards’ multiball cousin attracted more of an audience. 1933 saw the first national competition, a handicapped event open to amateur players around the UK. Much to the surprise of the organisers, around five thousand applications poured through the letterbox. Probably going to need a bigger hall, then. And yet, professional cuesmiths preferred to stick to billiards, only occasionally racking up the reds, meaning the growth in participants failed to result in much mainstream attention. Until the arrival on these shores of charismatic Canadian Conrad Stanbury.

    While not quite as adept at the sport as homegrown players like Joe Davis, Stanbury added a sense of style, humour and colour to the sport, a stark contrast to the relatively austere Brits. Fellow Canadian Clare O’Donnell also arrived in the UK, taking on well-known billiard pros at snooker, his quick-fire approach to play attracting even more interest in the sport. While the style of the North American duo attracted attention, it was the arrival of Australia’s Horace Lindrum that provided a true rival to top British player Joe Davis. The matches between the two being broadcast over the radio proved how the sport was becoming more popular, and by 1937 former billiards pros were spending more time playing snooker than its parent sport.

    In a passage that would prove to age particularly badly, the RT article on the Lindrum-Smith match suggests that it may well be that “the present popularity for snooker will turn out to be just a passing fancy, that the players will tire of constant potting, and welcome a return to cannons and long losers”. How wrong they would turn out to be. After all, snooker would go on to be the biggest game on green baize.

    Plus, it certainly didn’t hurt that its origin story can be explained in one of the finest sentences ever published:

    "The introduction of snooker is somewhat obscure, but the introduction of the game is attributed to Captain Snooker (hence the name), who was an officer in the Bengal Lancers in India".
    Now you’re glad you clicked on this post. Sadly, the above isn’t true, and the common understanding is now that it originated from the brain of Neville “Not That One” Chamberlain in 1875. But still, CAPTAIN SNOOKER.

    Though all that would come later. For now, it was deemed a sport not yet ready for the viewing public, small monochrome 405-line sets of the era perhaps not providing the optimal viewing experience. As such, following that initial pair of TV broadcasts for snooker on 14 and 16 April 1937, the sport wouldn’t return to BBC-tv (at least under a standalone billing) until 1950.

    The dawn of the atomic age didn’t do too much to make snooker a fixture on British TV, however. The decade only saw a smattering of matches broadcast, including “Walter Donaldson (Present World Champion) v. Joe Davis (Retired Undefeated World Champion)” in September 1950. Throughout the decade, the not-as-retired-as-you-may-have-thought Davis featured more than any other player, such was the box office (well, TV licence fee) appeal of the sport’s most decorated player. Even where he wasn’t a competitor in the televised game, such as 1952’s John Barrie-Rex Williams match, he would turn up to perform a few trick shots between frames, such was his appeal.

    Come January 1955, a special session of snooker was broadcast to mark the final event at snooker’s then spiritual home, London’s Leicester Square Hall, the centrepiece of the event being an exhibition match between Joe Davis and his brother Fred – himself no slouch on the baize, going on to win eight World Championships between 1948 and 1958.

    As the decade progressed, most snooker coverage was folded into the weekly Sportsview round-up, which featured a “Sportsview Potting Competition” that allowed keen cuesmiths to challenge a top professional. And not just in any standard game of snooker, but a specific layout that proved a little more exciting (and more suitable for a segment of a programme just thirty minutes long). Another strand that proved popular was a feature where Joe Davis – playing solo – would attempt to score as high a break as possible within two minutes. The sporting spectacle was slightly undone in one edition where the referee, displaying his keenness to replace a coloured ball as swiftly as possible, accidentally scattered the remaining in-play balls as he did so.

    The only standalone coverage of this era came from The News of the World Tournament, which pitted the best players against each other in a round-robin “American-style” format that was considered by many to be of greater importance than the ‘real’ World Championships – not least as the latter no longer featured people’s favourite Joe Davis.

    By 1958, Saturday sporting action was safely enclosed in a great big Grandstand umbrella, with initial episodes making great play of challenge matches featuring, inevitably, Joe Davis. And Grandstand provided a safe haven for snooker for much of the next decade, the sport providing a perfect alternative to throw to whenever an outdoor event found itself hamstrung by unpredictable British weather. However, acting as the sporting equivalent of a supply teacher was no life for a proud sport, and once the Beeb’s favourite player finally retired from the sport in 1964 (Joe Davis, as you’ll have guessed), it seems the BBC had lost interest in the sport. Basing much of your coverage around a single superstar in the twilight of his career hadn’t been much of a long-term plan, as it turned out. When Grandstand producer (and snooker fan) Lawrie Davies left the corporation for a role at Yorkshire in 1965, snooker coverage would also depart the BBC.

    Fred Davis vs Warren Simpson, 1960. See how disconcertingly close the crowd are. Anyone else feel a bit claustrophobic looking at this video?

    On the other side, ITV had been having a lot of success with tournaments largely based around the amateur snooker scene. In 1961, this had involved putting together a tournament that saw four top amateur players face off against a quartet of players from the then-tiny pool of professional players. The matches were in a much friendlier TV format – just five frames per match, broadcast live and being much more competitive than the BBC’s exhibition-match coverage – but given the nature of the game, an keener desire to win often led to cautious matches concluding off-screen, as ITV’s attention had long drifted to the classified football results.

    Still, what was there was more compelling than Grandstand’s coverage of the Joe Davis Globetrotters, especially in 1962 when amateur player Mark Wildman made the first ever televised century break on ITV, but with monochrome sets still in use, even that wasn’t enough to keep viewers queueing up (ignoring the easy snooker pun, there) for live coverage – especially when there’s no guarantee they’d get to see the final black of the final frame being slammed home. Conversely, matches being settled within just three of the five frames meant coverage finished much earlier than schedules anticipated, leaving a production team frantically trying to fill an additional hour and hardly resulted in tense, captivating snooker.

    This lack of popularity caused concerns for the Billiards Association & Control Council. If only more matches lasted the full five frames, and also happened to be wrapped up in a way that meant everything was done and dusted before the vidiprinter clicked into life with the football scores.

    Then… that started to happen. A lot more often. Wahey! Exciting snooker! This is what the public wants! Great job everybod… hang on, the Sunday Times have rumbled what’s been going on.

    The Sunday Times, 8 Sept 1968

    The real giveaway came on 28 January 1967. A invitation match on World of Sport between George Humphries and Ray Edmonds was billed as “a five frame thriller”. In the Sunday Times expose the following year, Edmonds came clean: “It was a five-frame thriller because we wangled it that way.”

    It hadn’t been easy. At least according to Edmonds, Humphries had been so off his game, Edmonds accidentally won the second frame of the match, and had to put in some concerted cackhandedness to lose the third and fourth frames. By the time the fifth – and only deliberately competitive – frame came around, both players were so full of yips both players struggled to regain any sense of form. And the viewing audience likely reasoned they’d see a more skilled session of snooker down at the local hall at chucking out time.

    This was far from a one-off. In the Sunday Times piece, former chair of the Billiards Association and Control Council Harold Phillips admitted that players of televised exhibition matches were given a reminder that “This is entertainment, you’re evenly matched and I do hope it’s all on the final frame”. Perhaps he followed that up by saying “wink wink”, the report doesn’t make it fully clear.

    The issue hadn’t been restricted to matches on ITV. Former world champ Fred Davis stating that the BBC would “look on [close matches] favourably, if you understand what I mean”. As a result, Davis began to treat his exhibition matches on the Beeb as “five frames of comedy”, adding that he hated “taking part in something that’s not genuine”. And so, with the scandal scaring ITV away from the sport and the BBC long having given up on it, snooker would be absent from TV screens entirely.

    That was, until the advent of colour television on BBC2 and the introduction of a brand new, and very different knockout tournament. One that wouldn’t need thrown frames to manufacture excitement.

    “Rarely can any sport, even on television, offer its supporters the top eight exponents of the game in one fifteen-minute appearance. Tonight BBC-2 does just that” boasted the Radio Times listing, and that’s exactly what was on offer here.

    Each Wednesday evening, sandwiched between a weighty fifty-minute documentary and an episode of Rowan and Martin’s Laugh-In, a single frame would be played between two of eight top players in a (largely) knockout competition, with one player winning the Pot Black trophy at the end of each series. For those new to the sport, the professionals would be on hand to offer advice (“instead of a pointer, these teachers use a billiard cue”), though given the modest fifteen-minute slot afforded early episodes, any lessons would need to be swiftly delivered.

    Despite the popularity of Pot Black, coverage of regular snooker matchplay was still restricted to the BBC’s generic sporting strands. That was to change in the late 1970s, with BBC producer Nick Hunter keen to capitalise on the popularity of the quickfire series. If pre-recorded single frames could attract a BBC-2 audience of four million, Hunter felt that full coverage of snooker tournaments – freed from the shackles of brief Sportsnight highlights – could prove a hit. Players like Ray Reardon and Alex Higgins were helping to forge a new image for the sport within Pot Black, maybe viewers would like to see more of them?

    The water was tested with highlights of the semi-final and final of the 1977 Embassy World Professional Championship being broadcast, and proved to be enough of a hit to expand coverage for the following year’s Championship. Late-night fifty-minute highlights packages were broadcast on each of the tournament’s two weeks, with live coverage included on each Saturday’s Grandstand, and live coverage of the final being broadcast on BBC-2. Despite the highlights airing in a slot nudging midnight, an audience of four million grew to seven million by the end of the tournament.

    No wonder it was so popular. What could be more romantic than A Review of the 1980 Embassy World Professional Snooker Championship?

    By 1980, viewing figures for latter stages of the World Snooker Championship topped 14m, increasing to 15.6m for the following year’s final. It didn’t hurt that the big tournaments were slimmed down to provide a more compelling spectacle. While final matches back in the 1940s would feature 145 frames spread across a fortnight (not necessarily all at the same venue), by 1981 it was down to a much friendlier Best of 35.

    With the coverage proving to be a hit, the number of hours broadcast from each tournament increased. And so did the viewing figures. Major matches soon found themselves being broadcast live on BBC-1, or passed between BBC-1 and -2 whenever trifles such as the News needed to be broadcast on the main channel, ensuring keen viewers wouldn’t miss any action. There was a junior edition of Pot Black. Ray Reardon appeared on Parkinson. Recaps of each spring’s World Championships were compiled for broadcast over Christmas.

    Cats and dogs living together etc.

    Snooker was conquering the country. At a time when going to a football match could end with you getting a dart in the eye, staying in to watch snooker seemed a much more attractive option. The prize money was growing, top players were becoming household names – at least 78% of Britain’s Dads would routinely put their glasses on upside down and say “look everyone, I’m Dennis Taylor!” throughout the mid-1980s. Even ITV tried to get back on board, but with several regional franchises snootily favouring their own programming in off-peak slots, the BBC was where the competition sponsors preferred their tournaments to be. Though ITV still cheekily snagged another TV snooker first, Steve Davis bagging the first-ever televised 147 during the light channel’s coverage of the Lada Classic.

    Cigarette companies couldn’t advertise in ad breaks on ITV, yet their products were being beamed into twenty million sets of eyeballs on the BBC, which helped fund generous tournament sponsorship packages. During actual programmes! It seemed the gravy train would never stop.

    Nice to see a world-class sportsman endorsing a product they actually use.

    The peak came, as every schoolchild knows, in the 1985 World Snooker Championship final, the match between Steve Davis and Dennis Taylor attracting the largest-ever BBC-2 audience, and the UK’s biggest-ever post-midnight audience, with 18.5 million viewers as Taylor’s final black finally went down.

    The other peak was, of course, this.

    Of course, nothing ever lasts forever (apart from Keith Richards and this list of TV programmes), and in 1990 something happened that would start to chip away at the all-conquering snooker mothership. And by ‘something’, I mean someone. And by ‘someone’, I mean Stephen Hendry.

    In the 1980s, snooker unquestionably had personality. Whether it was Dennis Taylor’s glasses, Bill Werbeniuk’s ability to claim lager as a business expense or Jimmy Whirlwind White, it just had something about it. Chas and Dave don’t just make records with anyone, you know. Even the player pilloried for being boring, Steve Davis, turned out to be a great guy, writing a comedy book, acting alongside David Cross in a US cable TV sitcom and then becoming an underground electronica artist (all true!). But Stephen Hendry came along and hoovered up most of the big snookering gongs for the next decade. Here was someone truly laser-focused on upping his game, who’d grown up in a world quite different to the fags and sleaze era of the sport. And, at the time of his first title, he was just 21 years old. He was going to be around for a long time to come.

    By 1992, snooker had the brand new (football) Premier League to contend with. And so, as one successful-but-dour Scot wowed supporters (and infuriated rival fans) as a refreshed sport wowed a growing TV audience, another started turning people away from his own. The blame didn’t land purely at Hendry’s sensible shoes, of course. Coverage had perhaps reached saturation point, and while the number of hours devoted to snooker on the BBC remained at a similar level for years to come, audiences started to decline. A series of more, well, professional professionals started to take hold, meaning any excitement for the casual viewer was restricted to seeing if Jimmy White could finally win the World Snooker Championship title. SPOILER: He couldn’t.

    And yet, as snooker started to wane in popularity in the UK, it began to grow in popularity elsewhere. Thailand’s James Wattana became the first Asian player to reach the semi-finals of the World Snooker Championship in 1993. By 2000, Hong Kong’s Marco Fu was ranked in the world’s top twenty players, soon to be followed by Chinese star Ding Junhui. Other Chinese players such as Liang Wenbo and Liu Song would soon join the list of ranked professionals as the sport grew in popularity throughout Asia, but the biggest name on the millennial snooker scene was very much homegrown.

    Ronnie O’Sullivan did more than anyone to bring to sport back to public attention, having bagged his first century break at the age of ten, and his first competitve 147 at the age of just 15. In 1997 he’d bagged the fastest competitive 147 in history, taking just over five minutes to notch a maximum break at the World Championships. Ferocious at the table and refreshingly outspoken away from it, O’Sullivan would go on to be as successful as any player in the modern era. But – crucially – his habit of collecting World Championship gongs was a little more spread out than Hendry’s reign of no-error, allowing others to win them once in a while. So, that’s nice.

    And best of all, he provided the sport with a redemption arc – slipping right down the world rankings from the early 2010s, slipping to 28th in the middle of the decade (albeit still picking up world titles in 2012 and 2013), before clambering back to the top in 2019, and regaining his world crown in both 2020 and 2022.

    Snooker still isn’t as popular as it once was. While other bar-room sports such as darts have enjoyed a massive rise in popularity since the turn of the century – the game of arrows having its own popular Premier League competition – snooker has never really attempted such a reinvention. And yet, it’s quietly retained a loyal audience, and it’s far less parochial than it once was. While the glitz and glamour of the sport once rose no higher than matches being played at Blackpool Tower, ranking tournaments now routintely take place in Latvia, China, Belgium or Germany, while still retaining a spiritual home at Sheffield’s Crucible. The British TV audiences may have slipped, but the global TV audiences are higher than ever.

    And best of all, current players are no longer expected to share a television studio with Jim Davidson. The sport has certainly come a long way.


    Blimey, that was an epic journey. Well done if you stayed awake through all that. Tune in again soon for the next update, and until then let’s all hold our collective breath that number eight on the list isn’t Big Break.

  • RECAP: The 100th to 51st Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time

    With the list about to visit that all-important Top, erm, Nine, let’s pause and take in the whole list so far, across two updates. Very much one for the TL;DR types, but nice to revisit even if you’ve been keeping an eye on the various updates.

    While compiling the newer entries on the list, I’ve dug out some extra broadcasts from the entire archive (either from newspaper listings where RT listings were unavailable, or individual shows within programme listings), so some of the numbers are tweaked from the original write-ups, as are (in a few cases) the positions on the list. Plus, the whole thing started so bloody long ago, it’ll be nice to revisit some of the programmes.

    So, here we go! Each programme name contains a link to the original write up for that show.


    100: Saturday Kitchen
    (Shown 891 times, 2001-2021)
    “If asked to name the second most frequently shown Open University programme of all time, you’d probably expect the answer to be ‘Geochemical Surveying’ or ‘Public Administration’ or something similarly dry. But nope, it’s Saturday Kitchen. Saturday. Kitchen.”

    99: Final Score
    (Shown 897 times, 1971-2021)
    “as is usually the case when it comes to football, The Football Results just seem to contain that little extra sense of gravitas when they’re on the BBC.”

    98: Put Your Money Where Your Mouth Is
    (Shown 917 times, 2008-2021)
    “Despite adopting a fairly well-worn format, PYMWYMI swiftly became a hit with viewers, and the programme would soon see itself spread across the schedules like high-end marmalade.”

    97: Z Cars
    (Shown 920 times, 1962-1998)
    ““I thought I was out. But then they dragged me back in” could be a line from any generic 80s cop film, where a grizzled LAPD Detective postpones his retirement to tackle one last case, just like he did in the previous four films in the series. The same could be said of Z Cars, had it been a sentient being capable of independent thought in addition to being a tremendously hardy continuing police procedural.”

    96: Sportsnight
    (Shown 934 times, 1968-1997)
    “Indeed, those who had been on the terraces would often hope to make it home in time to catch footage of any incidents only half-glimpsed, or blocked by a taller spectator in front of them. If nothing else, anyone who’d been at Selhurst Park on 25 January 1995 will surely attest to that.”

    95: Fimbles
    (Shown 937 times, 2002-2010)
    “the antics of Fimbo, Flurrie and Baby Pom proved popular enough, with the programme running on CBeebies for almost the entirety of the channel’s first decade, making the nascent channel’s weekly BARB top ten on 136 occasions”

    94: Five to Eleven
    (Shown 939 times, 1986-1990)
    “A world away from episode six billion of Homes Under the Hammer, I’m sure you’ll agree.”


    93: Rugby Special
    (Shown 976 times, 1966-2005)
    “Rugby. Sweat. Mud. Blood. Thunder. The North. Someone getting their ear torn off in a scrum. All soundtracked by Paddy Kingsland’s proto-electropop ‘Spinball’. So utterly marvellous it almost feels like a mistake.”

    92: For the Children
    (Shown 983 times, 1937-1952)
    ““a demonstration organised by the Camping Club of Great Britain and Ireland”, “Commander A. B. Campbell opens a sea chest and shows its treasures to the children”, “Model steam and power boats cruise on the lake at Alexandra Palace” and “Commander A. B. Campbell opens his sea chest again. This time the treasures come from Canada.””

    91: Postman Pat
    (Shown 1006 times, 1981-2012)
    “Henry Rollins once said “I believe that one defines oneself by reinvention. To not be like your parents. To not be like your friends. To be yourself.” Now, I’ve no idea about the context of that particular utterance, but I feel at least 85% sure he’s talking about Postman Pat.”

    90: Strictly – It Takes Two
    (Shown 1006 times, 2004-2021)
    “Personally, I’m still surprised that Come Dancing (a) even made a comeback that would become so popular, it felt like like seeing a peak-time celebrity reboot of One Man and His Dog (b) it would be so damn popular the format would be sold around the world (under a more sensible name, admittedly), and (c) that it did all that with such an unwieldy title. Presumably a play on the firm Strictly Ballroom, it doesn’t even work as a pun. Rubbish!”

    =87: Nai Zindagi – Naya Jeevan
    (Shown 1010 times, 1968-1982)
    “With just thirty minutes each week, and quite a lot to cover (you know, music, interviews, a round-up of news from an entire sub-continent), one can only imagine how difficult it must have been to prepare for each show.”

    =87: QI
    (Shown 1010 times, 2003-2021)
    “It ended up proving a huge success. In fact, it’s been so successful, it’s now part of a very exclusive group of programmes to have aired on BBC One, BBC Two, BBC Three and BBC Four. The whole set.”

    =87: The Simpsons
    (Shown 1010 times, 1996-2004)

    “Two things pretty much led directly to the dominance of Sky in today’s television market. One is Premier League football, 104 years of tradition being tossed aside for a new money-led project that went on to dominate the sporting world, and Sky Sports will forever be irrevocably tied to it. The other key factor: a certain five-member family from Springfield.”

    86: Laurel and Hardy
    (Shown 1047 times, 1948-2005)
    “Okay, here’s a thing. For the most part, if a programme is called something, it’s that something. In the case of beloved comedy duo Laurel and Hardy, it’s either one of their original films, or an episode of the 1966-1967 Hanna-Barbera cartoon of the same name. And quite frankly, one of these things is less than the other.”

    85: ChuckleVision
    (Shown 1056 times, 1987-2012)
    “A cultural touchstone for entire generations of children (and adults) across a quarter-century on our screens, and two of the absolute nicest people in showbusiness.”

    84: Murder, She Wrote
    (Shown 1065 times, 2002-2011)

    “What is perhaps most surprising of all is how Murder, She Wrote appeared so many more times on the BBC than contemporary US shows like Columbo (225 times, 1988-2003, 485th place), Ironside (514 times, 1967-2003, 187th place), or even the always-bloody-on-when-I-was-a-kid Bonanza (somehow only 220 showings between 1978 and 1988, 497th place).”

    83: Dad’s Army
    (Shown 1069 times, 1968-2021)

    “Here’s a programme that was always going to be On Ze List, but who would’ve thought it would be in as modest a position as joint-83rd?”

    82: The Magic Roundabout
    (Shown 1070 times, 1965-1985)

    “Without even bothering to check through the rest of the list, I’m just going to go out on a limb and state categorically that this is the highest-ranking French programme on the list.”

    81: In the Night Garden
    (Shown 1106 times, 2007-2012)

    “In short, if you’re a parent who ends up having to watch this programme every evening because it’s more suitable than what you really want to watch at 6.30pm, your mind really can’t help but overanalyse every little facet of the programme. Like: how come the Pontipine children are never taken into care? And why does to relative size of the characters keep shifting around so much in each episode? But hey, there might be someone good on Bedtime Stories in a bit.”

    80: The Phil Silvers Show
    (Shown 1107 times, 1957-2004)

    “But, let’s be honest here, The Phil Silvers Show isn’t just any American sitcom. As far as comfort-viewing sitcoms that transcend age and time go, I’d argue it’s (at least to British eyes) a stateside cousin of Hancock’s Half Hour.”

    79: Doctor Who
    (Shown 1139 times, 1963-2021)

    “as much of a Saturday fixture as Grandstand or Dad’s pool coupon going in the bin just after the classified results”

    78: Watchdog
    (Shown 1141 times, 1985-2019)

    “All together now: ‘“’Potential death trap.’”

    77: Wogan
    (Shown 1142 times, 1982-2010)

    “Wogan would air at 7pm each Monday, Wednesday and Friday, while upstart soap EastEnders would go out at that time on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Only one of them was an instant hit. And it wasn’t EastEnders.”

    76: University Challenge
    (Shown 1175 times, 1994-2021)

    “For the last few years, University Challenge has effectively teamed up with Only Connect each Monday evening at 8pm to provide a weekly “feel pleased with yourself if you get more than two questions right” hour of programming.”

    75: Great British Menu
    (Shown 1184 times, 2006-2021)

    “Long before Bake-Off became the default Google autocomplete option for ‘Great British’, another BBC2 cookery contest set a lofty bar for highfalutin haute cuisine.”

    74: Tom and Jerry
    (Shown 1192 times, 1967-2003)

    “Thomas Jasper “Tom” Cat Sr and Gerald Jinx “Jerry” Mouse would be an early evening fixture on BBC-1, forming a formidable triple-act with Simon Dee on Tuesday and Thursday evenings throughout 1967.”

    73: The Sky at Night
    (Shown 1201 times, 1957-2013)

    “Liiiiiive astronomy!”

    72: Call My Bluff
    (Shown 1218 times, 1965-2005)

    “Despite feeling like the very epitome of dry early 1980s BBC-2 output (well, it does to me), the programme actually had a much more glamorous birthplace: Studio 6A at NBC Studios in Manhattan’s Rockefeller Center.”

    71: Grange Hill
    (Shown 1252 times, 1978-2008)

    “Don’t you realise the way you act is influencing millions of children to talk cockney and be insubordinate?” “Come on sir, don’t be silly. We’re the only kids in Britain who don’t say…”

    70: Mastermind
    (Shown 1265 times, 1972-2021)

    “One’s a Trade Union leader, the other’s a member of the Cabinet.”

    69: Athletics
    (Shown 1295 times, 1946-2021)

    “And at a time where such output could easily have been hived off to BBC Three or the Red Button, it only proves how compelling the art of running, jumping and occasionally throwing stuff is to the Britain public.”

    68: To Buy or Not to Buy
    (Shown 1313 times, 2003-2012)

    “Hello and welcome back to Coverage of People Buying a House and Then Living In it. So, hello Jeff, you wanna buy a house, here’s a house.”

    67: Casualty
    (Shown 1336 times, 1986-2021)

    “chronologically-speaking, the first episode of Casualty was closer to the events of Casualty 1909 than to today.”

    66: Top Gear
    (Shown 1396 times, 1978-2021)

    “Well, here’s a thing. Something that started out as a regional programme in the Midlands, which would go on to become the most-watched motoring programme [theatrical voice] In The World.”

    65: Pingu
    (Shown 1404 times, 1990-2013)

    “Pingu went on to be broadcast around the world – pretty much everywhere except the USA, it seems. Even a 1993 rap single by David Hasselhoff about Pingu (no, really) didn’t win over the stateside audience.”

    =63: Antiques Road Trip
    (Shown 1449 times, 2010-2021)

    “Despite a programme name that makes it sound like an Aldi version of Antiques Roadshow, Antiques Road Trip is a very different proposition. Well, not that different. It’s still about antiques.”

    =63: Natural World
    (Shown 1449 times, 1983-2021)

    “With a reputation as the planet’s go-to broadcaster for high-quality natural history films, it’s little surprise so much talent could be coaxed into working on the series, but the narrator rarely took top billing in a series where wildlife always took centre stage.”

    62: Diagnosis Murder
    (Shown 1472 times, 1993-2011)

    “the show featured medical doctor Mark Sloan (played by D-word Van D-word) as he solved crimes in all the bountiful spare time medical doctors have.”

    61: Farming
    (Shown 1488 times, 1957-1988)

    “No longer would farmers finding themselves in the wrong region miss out on advice from W. S. Mansfield, Manager of the Cambridge University Farm, on topics such as grassland improvement, High versus Low Farming, or alternate husbandry (saucy).”

    60: Tomorrow’s World
    (Shown 1510 times, 1965-2003)

    “As the trope has it, a series inextricably linked to a nation of pop kids who just want TOTP to start already, Tomorrow’s World spent almost forty years tottering on the tightrope between reporting on scientific breakthroughs and entertaining a primetime BBC1 audience.”

    59: The Money Programme
    (Shown 1515 times, 1966-2011)

    “The suggestion didn’t go down too well with some executives at the Corporation, their reaction reportedly being that money was boring, and “the idea that there might be an audience for a regular TV programme on money struck producers as absurd.””

    58: Scooby-Doo
    (Shown 1522 times, 1970-2012)

    “And that programme was, of course, to be called… The Mysteries Five. And that five were: Geoff, Mike, Kelly, Linda and W.W., plus their bongo-playing dog, ‘Too Much‘.”

    57: Westminster
    (Shown 1567 times, 1970-2001)

    “Here’s one that seems unlikely to generate much excitement. But for much of it’s life, a programme that came with the unenviable challenge of not being able to show any footage of the thing they’re talking about.”

    56: Have I Got News for You
    (Shown 1578 times, 1990-2021)
    “And so, in a set that now looks claustrophobically close, Have I Got News For You thundered onto our screens at 10pm on Friday 28 September 1990. The main competition in that slot at the time was The Golden Girls on C4, and the Florida quartet initially pummelled the upstart panel show in the ratings.”

    55: Animal Park
    (Shown 1639 times, 2000-2021)

    “If you want an animal-based programme that seems as unstoppable as a rhino-led restaging of the rollerskating scene from Some Mothers Do ‘Ave ‘Em, then Animal Park is the show for you.”

    54: Coast
    (Shown 1644 times, 2005-2021)

    “Coast arrived on our screens in 2005 with a simple premise. You know the wiggly bit that runs around the periphery of the UK? Let’s look at that!”

    53: Twenty-Four Hours / 24 Hours
    (Shown 1684 times, 1965-1972)

    “Twenty-Four Hours does a magnificent job of covering such a breaking international story – it’s worth remembering that at this point, the entire medium of television is only thirty years old.”

    52: Holby City
    (Shown 1700 times, 1999-2021)

    “It’s perhaps notable that, despite the series being a soap opera (sorry, continuing drama). Holby City dealt purely in hour-long episodes, clocking up over 1000 episodes in its time. Indeed, that stack-em-high approach led to criticism, with Broadcasting Standards Commission director Paul Bolt accusing the BBC of squandering the television licence fee on the programme.”

    51: Breakfast Time
    (Shown 1727 times, 1983-1989)

    “A pastel coloured set strewn with sofas, a breezy theme tune and a bejumpered presenting team headed by Frank Bough, Selina Scott and Nick Ross eased Britain into each new morning, with a warming mixture of chat, interviews, horoscopes and advice.”


    Cripes, that took a long time to put together. Coming up very soon: numbers 50 to 10. And not too long after that, the all-important number nine.

  • DAMN, BALLS AND BLAST (the 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time, number, erm, 16).

    DAMN, BALLS AND BLAST (the 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time, number, erm, 16).

    Or, the follies of trying to cram a huge data analysis project into your vanishingly sparse amount of free time.


    Okay. This isn’t the first time this has happened, but it should be the last.

    Back when I started this ill-considered endeavour, right in the initial post, I mentioned that there will almost definitely be mistakes within the figures mentioned. All the data is taken from the (magnificent) BBC Genome project, most of which is taken from OCR-scanned issues of the Radio Times, and is therefore hostage to the limitations of both OCR software and the formatting quirks of the RT during any given period. That’s all fine when listings are picked up correctly by the BBC’s Genome Robot Army:

    3 Jan 1991: Nice, and how it should be.

    It’s a bit less fine during spells where the Radio Times uses a different layout to express daytime listings:

    7 Nov 1988: Not nice, and how it shouldn’t be. If you’re me, 35 years later.

    But: not to fret! I could just ignore these inconvenient listings, because almost-correct is better than nothing, right? Initially, that’s how I felt. Nobody has ever seemed to try doing something like this before, after all. There’s almost a million individual programme listings to calculate, nobody could reasonably expect it to be 100% correct.

    Except, y’know, it would bug the merry bloody hell out of me knowing there’s a 1988-sized gap in a programme’s data due to the way things were formatted at the time. The data is all thereabouts, ripe for the plucking. The only issue is: how to avoid the thorny bits (i.e. the thousands of instances where programme titles are only mentioned within programme descriptions)? How could I get around this, and get it all as accurate as possible? Individual episodes might squeeze through my big ol’ data net, but at least I can try to avoid any great big gaping holes. Somehow.

    So: what I went and did (warning: anyone who doesn’t give a flying fart about Excel can skip to the Natalie Portman meme below) was add in a column which contains a combined YEAR plus WEEKNUM in each cell, throw the whole dataset for each programme into a pivot table, and show =YEAR&”w”&WEEKNUM down the pivot’s vertical axis, then WEEKDAY along the horizontal axis. Any conspicuous gaps would be highlighted, then I can go digging for missing listings. Once I know which date ranges are missing, pull out Genome data for those weeks, and (using a really bloody bitty process involving Notepad++ and Excel filters) extract individual programme details within programme strands, all for the express purpose of seeing how often Jimbo and the Jet Set really got shown on BBCs One and Two (not as often as you might think, just 238 times, putting Jimbo into joint-489th place alongside Diddy Dick and Dom).

    It was a right royal pain in the arse, but OH THE IMPROVED ACCURACY OF IT ALL. I could finally sleep at night. Okay, I still couldn’t, but that’s because I’d been up until 2am staring at Excel on an overly bright monitor messing with all the data.

    And the dreams I’d have when I did get to sleep. Oh, the dreams.

    It wasn’t going to be perfect, but before publishing the entries for each programme, I’d do a more thorough check of each broadcast total. What’s the worst that could happen? Just before I click ‘publish’ on the entry for Grandstand, I might notice a gap, examine the missing dates and uncover another 27 episodes erroneously mis-scanned as ‘Grandsland’? It’ll only ever push it up the list a bit, I might need to write about the next programme instead, and have to publish the entry for Grandstand a bit later, but that’s fine.

    Hey, it’s not like an entry is suddenly going to have far fewer entries than I’d anticipated, is it?

    Hi, people who don’t care about Excel – welcome back. Here’s what you’ve missed: I’ve gone and been a bit too clever for my own good and bollocksed up. A bit.

    Basically, in noticing a large gap for One Particular Programme, I used trickery to fill in the gaps (and seriously, the alternative would’ve been filling in several hundred missing programmes manually, which I’ve already had to do too many times in this list), and things accidentally got duplicated. In short: I pulled a load of missing data through twice, and my checks to detect duplicates were thwarted by one set of data erroneously being listed as on BBC1 (gah, morning weekdays kids shows had moved to BBC2 at the time, as Daytime UK had started on BBC1 by then).

    In short: an entry was suddenly going to have far fewer entries than I’d anticipated. Which is a bit of a nuisance, as the Programme In Question was about to appear at Number 10 on the list. And now, on checking through the data, correcting the episode count and recompiling the list: it was actually in just 16th place on the list.

    Well, damn. That kind of undercuts my sense of satisfaction at finally reaching number ten on the rundown.

    I could’ve tried to save face and just gone with my initial, incorrect, episode count, just pretending everything was fine. But: nah, not going to do that. SO: the programmes that I’d initially placed as such:

    16: Match of the Day (Shown 4055 times, 1964-2021)
    15: Doctors (Shown 4081 times, 2000-2021)
    14: Escape to the Country (Shown 4365 times, 2002-2021)
    13: Grandstand (Shown 4500 times, 1958-2007)
    12: Flog It! (Shown 4530 times, 2002-2021)
    11: Jackanory (Shown 4701 times, 1965-2009)

    Are actually in the following positions:

    15: Match of the Day (Shown 4055 times, 1964-2021)
    14: Doctors (Shown 4081 times, 2000-2021)
    13: Escape to the Country (Shown 4365 times, 2002-2021)
    12: Grandstand (Shown 4500 times, 1958-2007)
    11: Flog It! (Shown 4530 times, 2002-2021)
    10: Jackanory (Shown 4701 times, 1965-2009)

    Dampens the impact of starting to announce the Top Ten, but fitting given the unique blend of intricate detail and rank amateurism you’d expect from my blog. If nothing else, I’m committed to meeting your expectations of this place. I’d have done it properly if I was being paid for this, honest.

    So, what’s in sixteenth place? Well, you may have already guessed given the illustrative images I used near the start of this entry. It’s…


    16: Playdays (née Playbus)

    (Shown 3908 times, 1988-2002)

    As time marches on, it’s increasingly easy to stumble across things that make you feel old. It can be cultural references that wholly pre-date the births of work colleagues (“sorry, what’s Ceefax?”), it can be seeing someone you went to school with on Facebook (“Nah, that must be someone middle-aged with a similar name who just looks a bit like them. Oh. Damn.”), but for me it was being raised on a diet of Humpty, Little Ted and The Round Window and subsequently seeing people banging on about The Why Bird. I felt alienated, a little afraid and out of touch with popular culture. Which is a bit of a wake up call when you’ve not yet reached puberty.

    At the time, Play School had been a preschool colossus. On the air since morning one of BBC2, it was the favourite of many a child. Me included.

    The big announcement that Play School was going through the exit window came on 5 October 1988. The programme that (due to circumstances) launched BBC-2 would be no more, and in its place would be something a little more up-to-date for the modern audience.

    However, before getting a chance to win over the key audience of two- to five-year-olds, it would first have to win the support of Britain’s parents, many of whom would have been grown up under the benevolent glow of the Play School house. A sense of continuity was to be instilled by way of former Play School producer Cynthia Felgate, who’d be sitting at the controls of the new tyke-friendly offering.

    The keys to Playbus were modernisation, new characters and a fresh sense of energy. No more Big Ted, no more cuckoo, and no more peering through windows. In came a programme designed to feel less middle-class, less cosy, and more urban.

    It was a gutsy move by the Children’s Department of the BBC, given the lack of threat to their loyal audience at the time. Channel 4 had all but given up on TV for younger children – the likes of Chips Comic had long fallen out of favour, and Pob’s Programme was in the middle of the five-year gap between its two series. Unless your younglings were weird enough to enjoy Murun Buchstansangur, the fourth network had little to offer them. ITV was still bothering with pre-school programming at lunchtime, but word in the press was that groups within the broadcaster would rather be using the slot for something more commercial.

    It’s quite likely the BBC was concerned about a different threat being beamed down from the skies. Satellite service BSB was readying itself for a launch, and despite having abandoned plans for a standalone kids channel at that point, were planning on handing a generous amount of airtime to children’s programming into their Galaxy entertainment channel. Ultimately, their modest subscriber base would pose little threat to Auntie Beeb, and it would be eaten up by a rival satellite service content to serve up imported cartoons (and DJ Kat) instead, but that future wasn’t on display in the Beeb’s crystal ball. As it turned out, Play School was still the biggest draw in the playground at the time, and it would likely have thrived had it been left alone. But hey, never hurts to have a bit of a refresh.

    So, Play School was to be knocked down to provide a clear road ahead for Playbus. And so, from 6 October 1988, the final few repeat episodes of Play School (the last of the new episodes having aired in March that year) were to be followed by five minute taster episodes of its successor, listed as ‘Playbus is Coming‘. Set to start on Monday 17 October 1988, this was the bright new future. Albeit one followed in the schedules by repeats of Arthur Negus Enjoys.

    The initial reaction was (and if any of this is a surprise to you: welcome to Britain) a general sense of despair at the very concept of change. Predictably enough, the Daily Mail were one of the first in line to spit the dummy over the change, with a full report and review from a group of disappointed critics. “Their bored little faces say it all,” it trilled. “Especially the mouth parts of their faces”, it should have continued, except they probably hadn’t heard of Jack Handey.

    YOUNG CRITICS' VERDICT ON NEW CHILDREN'S SHOW
THE BEEB MISSES THE BUS

THEIR bored little faces say it all. 

Britain's toughest TV critics had just watched the programme the BBC is banking on to replace its much-loved Play School. And they weren't too impressed. 

The show for three to six-year-olds is being launched next Monday to fill the gap left by Play School, which Corporation bosses believe had become out of date. 

It's called Playbus. But, judging from the preview they had in our living room yesterday, this is one bus my four-year-old son Joel and four of his playmates won't bother to catch. 

Things did not begin well. 

As soon as the tape of the show began Joel complained: 'Hey, this isn't Play School. Where's Play School?' 

His friend Kimberley Furber, four, took one look at the cartoon bus featured in the opening credits and decided it was time for a few backward rolls. 

George Dawson, three, left the room altogether, saying he wanted a hamburger. 

Brian Jameson, who will host the programme once a week, got a reception to chill the heart of any actor immediately he appeared oh screen with the words: 'Mv name is Brian and I'm driver of the bus.' 

'If he's a bus driver. Where's his badge?.' demanded Carly Fenton, four. 

'He's got a hat,' said five-year-old Laura Butler. 

But nobody seemed convinced. 

Things barely improved as the 20-minute show unfolded with Brian introducing his sidekick Whybird and a film on chocolate-making. 

'This bit's really boring.' they cried at one point. 

Only cartoon stories about Clive the Crocodile and Sidney the Spider proved a hit. They even got George buck from his hamburger hunt. 

When it was over, the children's verdicts were short and to the point.

Laura: 'It's all right I suppose. But who whs that man?' she meant Brian.

Kimberley 'I like Play School and Rainbow better.' 

Joel: 'It's only a bit nice. Play School's got better things to do ' 

Carly: '1 didn't think he was good.' Poor Brian again. 

George: 'Can I have my burger now?' 

The show's executive producer Cynthia Feigate is convinred she has the right formula with Playbus.

'Whilst the minds of young children do not change drastically, the world around them is changing constantly.' she says, 'Therefore their television programmes should be under regular review and not lie allowed to cling too closely to the past.' 

She should try telling that to Joel and his pals.
    Daily Mail, Thurs 13 Oct 1988 (full transcript in the alt text, detail fans)

    Despite a sceptical press, Playbus steadily built up a following. Children’s BBC was arguably at its peak around that time, with the corporation pumping £20m per year into the Children’s Programmes department, which resulted in approximately 900 hours of kid-focused programming per annum. That included prestige drama serials such as Tom’s Midnight Garden or The Chronicles of Narnia, the latter attracting audiences north of 10 million, but the less heralded programmes were no less impressive. From the winsome whimsy of Chucklevision, to educational fare like The Really Wild Show, to serious documentary strand The Lowdown, there was generally something for every taste. With some at ITV still grouching about the cost-ineffectiveness of producing Children’s ITV – especially with a costly franchise round looming in 1992 – the BBC was the best place for young viewers could to get that level of diversity.

    As it was, Playdays would follow the Play School template in many ways. Going out in a familiar slot each weekday, carrying an understanding that the audience would be travelling with them each day. And at least this time, the weekly ride would provide a bit more variety each day than Play School had offered.

    Mondays would be the Why Bird Stop, with the titular fowl dispensing various pellets of knowledge to the viewer. Tuesdays would provide a visit to the Playground Stop, where relatable footage of real children could be seen. Wednesdays would feature the Dot Stop, where the titular Dot (Rebecca Higgins) would offer sun with music and numbers. Thursdays would result in a visit to the Patch Stop, where nature and the environment would be on show. Fridays would seek to instil a sense of wonder and imagination in the viewers, with a trip to the Tent Stop.

    Each stop would have its own presenter and characters, and often attempt to tie in to seasonal or topical events (sadly not in the sense of Histor’s Eye, more along the lines of “let’s make some Easter stuff”). This concerted effort may have suggested a lack of faith in any one strand, and I can’t help but suspect the audiences attention may have flagged during the less popular stops. But, it did at least offer some scope for the individual ‘stops’ to evolve, so in 1992 the Dot Stop became the Roundabout Stop, offering puzzles, games and a dash of magic. Similarly, the Tent Stop would be replaced with the Poppy Stop, where a visit was made to Poppy the Cat’s house, allowing for cameo appearances from other characters from the series.

    Strangely, considering it was part of the televisual upbringing for children for fourteen years, Playdays (as it was for most of its run, the title changing from Playbus from Christmas Day 1989 following a complaint from the National Playbus Association) doesn’t seem to be imprinted anywhere near as prominently on Britain’s cultural wallpaper as Play School, or successor show Teletubbies. Maybe the stripped approach to those daily editions prevented it sticking to the national psyche in the way those other shows did? Maybe, for all the talk of appealing to a more modern audience, adopting a completely different approach (as Teletubbies would provide) might have been a better idea? Or maybe it was just one of TV’s great palate cleansers, a fourteen-year fade between the way Things Used To Be, and The Way Things Would Be?

    Don’t get me wrong, it was definitely doing something right – it clocked up almost 4000 showings on the main BBC channels during that tenure, but it seems relatively little of it remains in our collective consciousness. Maybe it just aired to a generation that would grow up less desperate to revisit the cultural ephemera of their youth? Admittedly, I’m just outside of the generation likely to have their names trip off the tongue, but to my mind the roster of Playdays presenters – the most notable of which were Zoe Ball and Dave Benson Phillips – doesn’t seem as memorable as that of Play School. I mean, yes, Zoe Ball is hosting one of Britain’s most popular radio programmes these days, but Floella Benjamin is a bloody Baroness, so checkmate.

    Not that Playdays didn’t make a bit of dough for BBC Enterprises. At the time there were lots of opportunities to bask in Playdays-related paraphernalia, with straight-to-retail VHS tapes aplenty, hardcover annuals, a long-running magazine, most of which being spin-off opportunities Play School left the stage too early for. Plus, there was a spin-off educational videogame that got on the cover of Your Sinclair.

    This *really* says a lot more about the lack of ZX Spectrum games being released in 1993. They had a grand total of two games to review in this issue, the other being budget re-release I, Ball 2. Unsurprisingly (if sadly), the magazine folded a few months after this issue.

    Playdays also displayed an impressive staying power. Despite no new episodes being made after 1997, the programme would continue to air on BBC channels, even after Teletubbies became a phenomenon both national and international, with the latter airing in the mornings on BBC2 (often twice per morning, such was it’s popularity), while repeat episodes of Playdays kicked off each afternoon’s CBBC strand on BBC1. By 2000, it was the repeats of Playdays that were deemed popular (or cheap) enough to be screened twice per weekday, in an early morning slot and at lunchtime. However, by 2002 BBC2 had the fresh-faced Tweenies to enrapture an audience of potty-enthusiasts, and Playdays was shuffled over to the digital-only CBeebies channel for a couple of years.

    After that, it was gone from our screens forever. At least for those without the foresight to stock up on Playdays VHS releases beforehand. For those who did… it was just a matter of waiting until 2023, and PAYDIRT. For everyone else: bye, Why Bird.

    A tenner for any pre-owned VHS is not to be sniffed at in this day and age.

    FACTS AMAZING: the day of the first ever episode (Monday 17 October 1988) also saw the debut of forgotten Brian Wilde vehicle Wyatt’s Watchdogs. That was that generation’s Barbie versus Oppenheimer.

    The Stage/TV Today, 13 Oct 1988

    (With thanks to Paul R Jackson for detail on the last few months of Play School being repeat episodes, and the detail of the final ‘new’ episodes having aired in March 1988.)


    There, another one down, albeit in completely inconvenient circumstances. Next time: we go inside number nine.

  • The 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (12 and 11)

    The 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (12 and 11)

    Back with a pair of shows that come as close as you can imagine to the final Top Ten.


    12: Flog It!

    (Shown 4530 times, 2002-2021)

    Waiting. There’s something that should be obsolete in this day and age. If you order something off the internet, you want it to arrive the next day. If you want to watch a film, you want to be able to stream it right away, even if you’re just looking at your phone while queuing at the deli counter in Sainsburys. And, I think I speak for us all, if you’re just had your grand-grandmother’s favourite urn valued on Antiques Roadshow and you want to cash in, you want the cash THERE and THEN. Not taking it home, sitting up all night with a baseball bat in case burglars have overheard the valuation, and carefully taking it to an antique dealer hoping to get the full promised amount. I mean, who’s got time for that? Gimme gimme gimme. Now.

    Well, if you’re anything like as impatient as I am, Flog It! is the show for you. The formula is much the same as that of Antiques Roadshow – members of the Great British Public bring their heirlooms along to a picturesque location somewhere in the UK, where they might be examined and valued by a resident expert, all under the watchful gaze of host Paul Martin. The main difference is that the owners of antiques are then given the option to sell their items at auction, giving a sense of closure to the viewer and (hopefully) a pocketful of cash for the owners.

    More details on this on the Scunthorpe Telegraph website.

    Occasionally, it takes more than mere pockets to contain the full value of items discovered by the programme. A 2013 episode filmed at Lincolnshire’s Normanby Hall saw Cleethorpes resident Ann Bromley bring in a collection of African tribal art, with resident expert Michael Baggott estimating the lot to be worth between £200-£400. That’s not too shabby, if nothing else it comfortably covers the petrol money for getting thete. Off to auction it went, only for everyone to learn this wasn’t of African origin at all. The collection, long left in a Cleethorpes wardrobe, turned out to contain a rare Australian Aboriginal shield, and was subsequently sold at auction for £30,000, having been bought by the Sydney Museum of Primitive Art.

    Unlike similar programmes of that ilk (Antique Roadshow, Antiques Road Trip), what had seemed an unstoppable juggernaut finally juddered to a halt in 2020, when the programme had been cancelled to make way for more contemporary fare. However, something that huge doesn’t just come to a halt – that’s just plain physics. Indeed, we still haven’t reached the end of Flog It!’s stopping distance, at the time of typing a variety of episodes from the last few series are going out each evening on BBC Two, seven days per week. Basically, the ineffective cancellation since the latest political berk banging on about being cancelled from the comfort of their £100k/annum gig on TalkTV.

    Of course, it’s not a proper long-running daytime strand unless it’s flanked by spin-off programmes, and Flog It! was no slouch there. Alongside highlight compilation show Flog It! Ten of the Best (broadcast 53 times, 2007-2009), there was Flog It! Travels Around Britain (broadcast 20 times, 2010-2016), which saw Paul Martin leave antiques behind to explore the influence of nature in art. The most successful spinoff arrived in 2013, with Flog It: Trade Secrets (broadcast 380 times, 2013-2020). This saw Paul Martin and his merry band of experts revisit the history of the parent programme, while dispensing advice on getting the best out of car boot sales and charity shops.

    Nothing like playing a charity shop for a chump, eh? Oh, Paul.


    11: Jackanory

    (Shown 4701 times, 1965-2009)

    Some television programmes manage to generate a lot of publicity by attracting famous names to take part. Sometimes, it’s Morecambe and Wise employing the likes of Shirley Bassey, Sir Laurence Olivier, Peter Cushing and Vanessa Redgrave for high-level japery. Sometimes, it’s Shooting Stars employing the likes of Larry Hagman, Robbie Williams and Curtis Steigers for top-tier titters. And sometimes it’s Ricky Gervais getting Johnny Depp, Robert de Niro and David Bowie to be in his programmes. But there’s also a much less heralded programme that, in its pomp, attracted a guest list including (amongst hundreds of others) Judi Dench, Denholm Elliott, David Suchet, Joyce Grenfell and Ian McKellen. Oh, plus some chap now known as King Charles III.

    Despite the star-studded future it would enjoy, Jackanory began under far more modest circumstances. With the BBC needing to output hours of children’s television each week, there was always a pressing need to produce content that could be worthy and captivating for the kids, but not everything could have the budget of a Blue Peter or Vision On. And so, Jackanory was born.

    Since 1950, radio series Listen With Mother had proved that a premise as simple as somebody reading out children’s stories over the airwaves would provide a welcome respite for harried parents, and in the 1960s former Listen With Mother producer Joy Whitby – by now having moved to TV – wondered if such a premise could also work on screen. It was fair to say Whitby had built up a decent track record, having devised BBC2’s pre-school smash Play School, which featured a daily section where a short story was read to the audience.

    Guest readers and simple illustrations helped capture the attention of Britain’s TV tots, and so Whitby was asked to develop that idea into a standalone teatime show for older children, with a target age of 8-to-11, over on BBC1. Given a six-week trial run, Whitby added Play School producers Anna Home and Molly Cox to the ranks, with the first story (traditional fairy tale Cap of Rushes, read by actor Lee Montague) going out on Monday 13 December 1965 in the pre-Blue Peter 4.45pm slot.

    Daily Mirror, Mon 13 Dec 1965

    The scheduling helped the new programme gather an audience, Whitby’s idea being that the timeslot would attract passing attention of adults as they returned home from work, and the involvement of mainstream actors would help keep their attention fixed firmly on the screen, sharing in the stories being read to the kids. That first six-week run also featured actors Wendy Hiller (a year before her third Oscar nomination for A Man for All Seasons) and Hattie Jacques, along with author Enid Lorimer.

    The programme proved to be a instant success. As the programme neared the end of that initial six-week run, a commission came for the series to continue running throughout the year. The fact it was a relatively inexpensive premise – a welcoming narrator reads a story (or series of short stories) over the course of a week, all from the same sparse set, meant little production lead time was needed, meaning it could continue without the need to retool. But while it didn’t need the longest credit roll at the end of each episode, it also meant the programme wasn’t initially deemed worthy of a place in the BBC archive, with many editions from 1960s and 1970s being wiped shortly after transmission

    Within a year of the first edition of Jackanory, the programme was deemed to be so firmly affixed to the zeitgeist, a selection of celebrity narrators were invited onto Late Night Line-Up to discuss the show. Margaret Rutherford, at that point dozens of films into her acting career, proclaimed the experience to be a fairly terrifying vocational detour, while James Robertson Justice expressed how he’d needed to rely on the more than capable guidance of producer Molly Cox to get through his initial Jackanory week.

    It didn’t take long before being asked to narrate a week of Jackanory was deemed a badge of honour for actors. Luckily, being able to call on the talents of top actors proved to be a boon for the production team, with the programme’s modest budget allowing little time for outtakes, so the more adept at delivering lines a narrator was, the better. It also certainly didn’t shy from attracting faces the target audience might not be too familiar with, such as Spike Milligan, Dudley Moore and Alan Bennett (the latter, of course, seen more as a white hot satirical firebrand than the literary teddy bear he’s now regarded as [SUB: PLEASE CHECK]). It’s almost tempting to add “much to the bafflement of watching children” here, except the same was far from true a few decades later when Rik Mayall narrated George’s Marvellous Medicine. My school was certainly abuzz with excitement about it in advance, so feel free to ignore that thought.

    Part of the programme’s strength was in the range of stories being relayed to its young audience. Joy Whitby saw it as her mission to introduce viewers to stories they might not ordinarily encounter. So along with classics like The Railway Children, The Tale of Johnny Town-Mouse or The House at Pooh Corner, you could expect to hear retellings of folk tales from Africa, Scandanavia, India or Russia.

    Contemporary stories from more modern authors were also regularly featured, and in October 1968 the doors were opened to the next generation of young authors, with a week of stories written by the winners of a ‘Write a story of Jackanory’ competition. Possibly anticipating a modest number of entries, the Jackanory team found themselves sifting through more than 6,000 entries from hopeful young scribes. From that bumper mailbag, the most popular genre of story was magic, followed by adventure and science fiction – the eventual winners being as young as four-and-a-half year old David Osrin (his story reportedly dictated to his frantically scribbling mother), and entries arrived in formats ranging from bound booklets to scribbles across their parents’ newspaper. By the end of that week, ten young storytellers found themselves in possession of a three-guinea book token and at least a term’s worth of playground bragging rights, ensuring the Jackanory Children’s Week would remain a feature for years to come.

    One key part of Jackanory was that illustrations were used throughout each story. Invaluable in helping the audience feel a connection to each story (at least they were if you had an attention span like mine), and in helping differentiate the programme from radio mentor Listen With Mother, the artwork was initially created by a small team of in-house BBC graphic designers. With the programme running five days per week throughout the year, to paraphrase The Simpsons, this put a tremendous strain on the illustrator’s wrists. This meant that illustrators had to take a production line approach to working, while juggling their desire to get their best work onto the screen. Deadlines were regularly straddled as the episodes were prepared, with the team of illustrators keenly flicking through each incoming story with a mixture of excitement and despair on spotting the most thrilling-but-busy scenes within each tale. (“Ooh, a sword fight! Gah, at a lavish banquet!”)

    Occasionally, the artistic licence taken with Jackanory illustrations required the involvement of the showrunner. In the splendid BBC Four documentary The Story of Jackanory, illustrator Graham McCallum tells of the time Joy Whitby had to request an illustrator nip down to the studio immediately, as a horse being featured in a pivotal scene had been drawn with a little too much, erm, front tail on show.

    In the 62nd volume of literary journal Something About The Author, illustrator Gareth Floyd (above) refers to the demands that came with his twelve years on Jackanory. The production team had seen Floyd’s illustrations in children’s books and offered him a freelance gig working for the programme, having quite sensibly realised the in-house team were being stretched that bit too far. Having worked on a couple of Jackanory commissions per year, including standout stories Stig of the Dump and The Railway Children, Floyd would be expected to provide sixty pictures for a week’s worth of episodes, a process made tricker by his usual style proving unsuitable for broadcast TV (not ‘unsuitable’ in that sense, you filthy lot):”My usual style had been to draw in pen, then in colour in a sort of two-wash drawing. That technique presented a problem on television where you tend to get a strobing of lines, the effect of lines crossing, [so] a more painterly style is often more suitable for television illustrations.”

    The relentless demand for fresh artwork being piped through to the studio proved too much for some, as Floyd recalled: “It’s not easy to finish sixty pictures on a tight schedule, and you can’t be late with material for television. Once the drawings were done I had to go to the studios and spend about three days altering details. I had heard many stories of illustrators who couldn’t take the strain. The producer would have to finish the drawings because the artist was too traumatised to go on.”

    Not all Jackanory illustrators would feel that much strain, however. It’s probably safe to say the most well-known of the freelance illu strators to work on the programme was Quentin Blake, who took a quite different view. Speaking in The Story of Jackanory, Blake recalls how he used to think “they’re only going to see this for several seconds! Whoopee!”

    Not that his near-minimalist style was unsuited to the show, of course. The energy, character and sheer joy contained within each Blake scribble brightened any episode to feature them. Little surprise that he’d work on more than 150 episodes of the series. Slightly more surprising that Blake would go on to present several episodes of the series in the 1970s, drawing illustrations for the Adventures of Lester stories as he went. The need to be constantly facing his canvas meant that, unlike most of the presenters on the programme, Blake would need to remember his stories word-by-word rather than read them from autocue. So it’s probably fortunate that Blake had written all the original Lester stories himself.

    Pictured: One of the great British multimediaists of our time.

    Back with the traditional setup, there were two sets of steady hands that kept the ‘Nory stable more often than any other: Bernard Cribbins – who’d go on to host the charming CBeebies pseduo-‘Nory Old Jack’s Boat until 2015 – and Kenneth Williams. With the latter, Williams’ distinctive performance as half of Round the Horne’s Julian and Sandy brought him to the attention of director Jeremy Swan, who approached Anna Home about getting him to take a turn as presenter. On receiving the offer, Williams expressed concern over the role, almost turning it down, having been informed he’d need to wear a huge hat bearing the illuminated legend ‘Jackanory’ throughout each recording – a particularly cheeky fib relayed to him by a mischievous Hattie Jacques. Fortunately for a generation of kids, Williams’ fears were allayed, and his marvellous vocal mannerisms would go on to feature in a total of 69 ‘Nory episodes.

    Such was the popularity of the programme, the brand was extended to cover full-on dramatic stagings of stories in spinoff Jackanory Playhouse – twenty-five minute programmes with full casts – running between 1972 and 1980. This helped whet the BBC’s appetite for producing more proper drama programmes within the Children’s Television hours (rather than standalone family dramas placed elsewhere in the schedule), some of which would be adapted from stories previously read in (standard) episodes of Jackanory, such as Jonny Briggs (Jackanory 1977-1984, standalone programme 1985-1987) or The Borrowers (Jackanory 1967 and 1983, standalone series 1992). Sadly though, it would be the growing popularity of standalone drama series that spelled the beginning of the end of Jackanory.

    By the mid-1980s, with Children’s BBC putting out a range of pre-recorded drama ranging from The Box of Delights to Grange Hill, the promise of a bejumpered Martin Jarvis reading tales from a sitting room seemed a little less essential, and having started taking summers off in the late 1970s, from 1985 Jackanory was a treat served only during the first few months of each year.

    If you’re wondering, that gap in 1975 was down to a mixture of ‘More Sport’ and the ‘BBC Being Skint’

    That didn’t mean the programme was going without a fight, however. The introduction of more contemporary storytellers such as Rik Mayall (George’s Marvellous Medicine in 1986 and The Fwog Pwince – the Twuth! in 1993, Jack and the Beanstalk on Christmas Eve 1995) or a pre-Marion Tony Robinson (Theseus the Hero in 1985 – adapted by Richard Curtis and Robinson, Odysseus in 1986, Terry Jones’ Nicobobinus in 1988, and Skulduggery in 1993). Robinson’s stories took to location filming, often involving members of the public, which definitely provided a fresh energy to the series.

    Series producer Angela Beeching remarked in The Story of Jackanory that Mayall’s episode had been the popular week of Jackanory in the programme’s history, and (predictably) one of the most complained about1. Oh, 1980s parents. Little wonder that Rik’s inaugural week of Jackanory would be repeated on Children’s BBC in 1988, again in 1994. Plus, once the original audience was somewhat older, again on BBC Four in 2006.

    In 1990, the programme’s 25th anniversary was marked by a series of greatest hits, with some of the most popular Jackanory narrators (Patricia Routledge, Bernard Cribbins, Tony Robinson) reading stories by some of the nation’s favourite Jackanory story authors (Joan Aiken, Helen Cresswell and, ah, Tony Robinson). However, the victory lap did little to disguise falling viewing figures. From a 1970s peak of five million viewers, the early 1990s saw audiences averaging around two million (yes, that’s a lot nowadays, but shush). The number of episodes airing in the weekday CBBC strand fell from 64 to 48 episodes per year between 1992 and 1993.

    A new producer, Nel Romano, joined the series in 1993, and attempted to bring the storied programme a little more up to date without losing that key identity. In a world with many more distractions to compete with, something new was needed to distract kids from switching to their SNES on AV2. In came another injection of energy, with narrators more normally seen after the watershed like Adrian Edmondson (Diana Hendry’s Harvey Angell, 1993), Kathy Burke (Roald Dahl’s The Twits, 1995) and Paul Merton (Morris Gleitzman’s Misery Guts, 1993). The intent was clearly to make clear how cosy old Jackanory was now anything but. Sadly, the move did little to increase viewing figures and on Friday 31 March 1995, Jackanory aired for the last time in a weekday CBBC slot, returning that October in a Sunday morning slot on BBC2, where stories would be delivered in a single, longer programme.

    That new home for the programme started with a determined effort to make the most of things, the first episode of the series marking thirty years on air by bringing back Bernard Cribbins for a tribute to fellow ‘Nory favourite Roald Dahl. Subsequent episodes would see contemporary figures like Pauline Quirke, Mike McShane and Diane-Louise Jordan take to the storybook. Despite those efforts, the early start needed to catch Jackanory meant that viewing figures continued to decline, and in 1996 the original Jackanory was given the chop.

    To close things off on Sunday 24 March that year, in came a classic pairing: Alan Bennett and Winnie the Pooh, a duet originally performed in a 1968 episode of the programme.

    That wasn’t quite the end for the series, however.

    The Sunday morning BBC2 slot was handed over to a run of Jackanory Gold from October 1996, starting with Arthur Lowe reading Peter Hughes’ The Emperor’s Oblong Pancake from 1976. That run would last until December 1997, but Jackanory’s legacy continue for years to come.

    Cue the new BBC channels, with Choice and Knowledge being hungry binary beasts desperate for content. It was BBC Knowledge that took up repeat runs of classic Jackanory from 2001, and better yet, in 2006 a fresh batch of Jackanories arrived on the new standalone CBBC channel, with taster episodes also going out on BBC One. The new episodes were perhaps now more at home on a channel with more modest expectations for viewing figures, but it was only ever a short-term concern.

    More success was made of another spinoff, with Jackanory Junior airing on CBeebies (and the CBeebies morning strand on BBC2). Stars such as Lenny Henry, Martin Clunes and Art Malik delivered a combination of stories old and new, keeping the Jackanory brand on the main BBC channels until 2009.

    From there, the Jackanory name faded into the background, with early morning Jackanory eventually morphing into the early evening CBeebies Bedtime Stories, with one-off five minute tales delivered by a variety of famous faces right before the channel bids sleepy-bye to the digital multiplexes for the night. And, given the fragmentation of viewers across the digital landscape, it’s a format that remains resolutely popular. The stories are still interesting enough to command attention, and with famous names ranging from Tom Hardy to Dave Grohl on hand to read them, it’s every bit as big with parents as the little ones.

    It might not quite match the full-on energy of George’s Marvellous Medicine, but it all brings in nicely back to the simpler original age of Listen With Mother on The Light Programme.

    EXCITING BONUS FACT: My wife’s grandad once had a gig building props for the BBC, one of which was the Jackanory kaleidoscope. That’s good, isn’t it?

    That was quite a long one, wasn’t it? And so, we’re at the end of the 100-11 part of the list. Yikes. Come back soon for the start of the ULTIMATE TOP TEN.


    1. Not that this was the only instance of innocent old Jackanory receiving complaints. The retelling of Ted Hughes’ The Iron Woman in 1994 draw complaints for the accompanying model footage, while a much earlier episode referring to Walter Raleigh being sent to ‘The Bloody Tower’ (i.e. Tower of London) compelled at least a few angry parents to call the BBC Duty Office at the shocking use of swearing on kids’ TV. ↩︎
  • Splashdown! It’s The 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (14 and 13)

    Splashdown! It’s The 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (14 and 13)

    It’s Saturday. It’s 12:15pm. The Weatherman just told us how rubbish the weather this weekend will be, so it’s time for… um.


    14: Escape to the Country

    (Shown 4365 times, 2002-2021)

    Richie: “Still, I did my bit for the country.”

    Eddie: “What, you stayed in the town?”

    Richie: “Absolutely.”

    Now admittedly, and it might be my own personal circumstances at play here, but it does seem like the much of this chart falls into one of two categories. Category One is all the programmes that have been part of the TV landscape throughout what feels like our entire lives: your Panoramas, your Matches of the Day, your Songses of Praises. Category Two comprises programmes that seem to have amassed a huge episode count seemingly out of nowhere, mainly due to the camouflage of being on when most people are at work, college and/or school. That category includes The Daily Politics, Ready Steady Cook, Cash in the Attic and this next entry on the list.

    For those who usually find themselves working/learning/sensibly doing something else when it’s normally on, Escape to the Country falls firmly into the Someone Buying A House And Maybe Living In It genre, and as these things go, it’s a pretty big deal. Generally, the action involves potential home buyers tiring of life in the Big City, and are surprised to learn that their two-bed London terraced home is worth a cajillion pounds, so they’re off to buy something massive near some fields.

    I mean, very nice, but how fast is the broadband there?

    The buyers will look at three or four suitably sprawling properties in their chosen location, including one ‘mystery house’ chosen by the production team. SPOILER: The mystery home isn’t haunted or anything fun like that, it’s basically just Another Very Nice House But The Kitchen Is Upstairs Or Something. Once all that’s done, the buyers are asked to guess the asking prices of each house, the real asking prices are revealed, and they’re asked to reveal which one they’d like to buy. And sometimes they do, which provides some material for a future episode.

    As far as I’m personally concerned, it’s something to angry up my blood as I spend an unhealthy amount of time working and still need to consider selling an internal organ whenever it’s time for a big supermarket shop. However, for many it’s clearly a lovely little slice of afternoon escapism. Not everyone is cynical as me, and feels happy for some people who can sell the Balham semi they paid £3000 for in 1978 and can subsequently afford to buy a third of Leicestershire. And that’s only partly a lazy assumption, by the way. The Independent on Sunday picked out the first episode as a Pick of the Day back in October 2002, their write up casually mentioning “an extended family from Basildon, who have a budget of £600,000, are looking for a mansion in Derbyshire”. Ooh, let’s all root for the plucky ragtag family. Collective prayer that they get a mansion they like, everyone.

    But anyway.

    The programme began all the way back in October 2002, in a mid-afternoon BBC2 slot, arriving with the following billing in the Radio Times:
    Hoping to “go green”, a young London couple want a country house. Catherine Gee gives them some options, in the first of a new series in which city-dwellers wanting to move to the country are found homes.

    It would quickly go on to become a regular for the channel, proving popular enough to receive a short repeat run on weekday morning BBC1 in the run-up to a new series in October 2004. At the time, the premise of the programme focused on families looking to leave behind the urban rat race for a rural idyll, but much of the initial ‘action’ involved the potential buyers viewing potential homes on a laptop in their city house, picking a pair of dwellings to visit in person, along with a third ‘mystery’ house. Ooh, mystery house, that’s a bit spooky… oh, it’s just that one bedroom is behind a big curtain.

    From the sixth series onwards, all four potential homes would be viewed in person by the buyers, along with a ‘taster’ day where the contributors are invited to sample delights of the local community, learn a little about the area and visit a few local attractions. A few series later, the number of homes was reduced to just three – retaining, obviously, The Mystery House (attic smells of tuna, third bedroom exists only in two dimensions, etc). And that’s where the format pretty much landed for the final time – it’s stayed that way ever since.

    In September 2012, as Escape to… neared its testimonial anniversary, first-run episodes were promoted to plum afternoon slots on BBC One, though revised repeats of the series had been airing on BBC One in a similar slot since 2009. In fact, the programme has been the initial beneficiary of BBC One ending the channel’s long-running Children’s BBC strand, which had been in place since the early days of the Television Service, that first non-CBBC late afternoon schedule in December 2009 dominated by a young couple’s quest to find an East Sussex home with a suitably huge kitchen.

    Such longevity would usually generate a spin-off or two, and that’s very much the case with Escape to the Country. January 2017 saw the first episode of catch-up series I Escaped to the Country, with  currently in its seventh series, and there was even a variant looking at those lucky enough to escape Normal Island in 2014’s Escape to the Continent. And, if rural living doesn’t butter your crumpet, 2019 saw the first episode of Escape to the Perfect Town, catering for those who get antsy if they wander too far from a Tesco Metro.

    There’s even an Australian version of the series, Escape from the City airing on ABC from 2019. Indeed, the original UK version is popular enough in the antipodes to have warranted a pair of Region 4 DVDs from Aussie disc supremos Shock Entertainment – a pair of box sets totalling nineteen discs.

    “Quality of life, Stu.”

    It’s even made a (modest) impact in the US, with the programme having appeared on US Netflix and Prime Video. Not a bad feat getting traction where huge houses are largely the default setting in all but the bigger cities, but it’s in the UK where Escape to the Country is truly an immovable feast.


    13: Grandstand

    (Shown 4500 times, 1958-2007)

    By the 1950s, the BBC Television Service had a problem with sport. Basically, it kept bursting out everywhere – especially on Saturdays – and it HAD to be contained. 1954 had seen the introduction of midweek sporting roundup Sportsview, which arrived with a mission to enthral viewers with the latest news, views and personalities from the world of sport. All very good, but with a runtime between twenty and thirty minutes on any given week, there was only so much room for actual sporting action. Conversely, on Saturday afternoons there was lots of space to broadcast live sport, the resulting BBC-tv schedule akin to a bull let loose in a Sports Direct. Sport was ruddy well everywhere. Live sports coverage was exempt from the Postmaster General’s broadcasting hours restrictions, so Saturday afternoons were pretty much a Linekeresque tap-in for BBC schedulers.

    Picking a Saturday at random to give an example, 8 September 1956 saw the following schedule in the Radio Times:

    1.50pm: Twenty minutes of Motor Racing from the British Automobile Racing Club’s September Meeting at Goodwood, including The Madgwick Cup, a five-lap race for cars up to 1,100cc. But no time to focus on that, because at 2.10pm viewers were whisked away to the Derby Baths in Blackpool for the National Swimming and Diving Championships. But don’t get too attached to that, because at 2.25pm we’re back off to the Motor Racing for twenty minutes, then back to the Derby Baths at 2.45pm. Who will win the big prize there? You’d better hope it’s decided by 3pm, because then we’re off to Farnborough for an Air Display by the Society of British Aircraft Constructors.

    Phew, eh? There really should be a little more order to this kind of thing.

    Luckily, a set of steady hands were on the way to steady the Saturday sporting tiller. Programme editor Paul Fox, production assistant Bryan Cowgill and presenter-cum-head of Outside Broadcasts Peter Dimmock had all worked wonders within the BBC’s Outside Broadcast team, Fox having created and edited Sportsview (plus the annual BBC Sports Personality of the Year, originally known as Sports Review of the Year), while Dimmock had proved his broadcasting mettle by taking charge of the BBC-tv’s coverage of the Queen’s Coronation, as well as working as main presenter of Sportsview. But it was Cowgill who had an idea that would transform weekend television for decades to come: an umbrella approach to the Saturday sporting portfolio.

    Mind you, Peter Dimmock wanted it to be called ‘Out and About!‘, so nobody’s perfect.

    Peter Dimmock’s stock was certainly high at the time. In the run-up to ITV’s big launch in 1955, the new network had been prepared to offer hefty pay increases to coax the BBC’s top talent over to the Light Network. Then-DG Sir Ian Jacob, displaying the sense of stoicism and stinginess you’d expect from the BBC of the 50s, was largely reluctant to match any such offers, him being well aware that the BBC’s more limited budget would necessitate cuts elsewhere offset any pay jumps.

    That wasn’t the case when Director of Television Sir George Barnes rang up to let him know about ITV’s approach to Peter Dimmock. The response from the DG was definitive: “Make any sort of personal relationships for him – as a personal case – that are necessary.”

    That was a decision borne of much more than keeping that friendly sports presenter on screen. Dimmock had displayed a special skill in negotiating sports contracts, and in selling the BBC programmes those contracts generated to overseas broadcasters. He’d also built up a series of working relationships with various sporting authorities, which combined with his ease at presenting live sport coverage made for a pretty comprehensive package. On top of everything else, he headed the BBC’s Outside Broadcasts Department, and had served as Sports Adviser to the European Broadcasting Union. If he hopped channels, any replacement would need one hell of a CV.

    Dimmock’s experience at working with the Outside Broadcasts Unit would be essential. He’d been a key component in TV coverage of the Queen’s coronation in 1953, serving as producer for coverage of the Coronation Service from Westminster Abbey, having worked closely with sceptical Abbey personnel to prove that the presence of TV cameras need not be a distraction from the main event. Before then, he’d worked on the 1948 Olympics, the first international relay from Calais in 1950 and the funeral of George VI in 1952.

    Having been so instrumental in several of the biggest moments in BBC-tv’s life thus far, throwing to live racing from Haydock was hardly a herculean task. Having seen teleprompters in use during his time in the USA, he know how to get the best out of the nascent tech while live to air. In short, the only person who could hope to keep all the levers moving when it came to launching the BBC’s new, sprawling and enthralling Saturday spectacular: Grandstand.

    Arriving on Britain’s screens for the first time on 11 October 1958, this was to no small undertaking. A shade under three hours of live television each Saturday, mostly, though not exclusively, devoted to sport – this was a programme from the BBC Television Outside Broadcasts department, after all. Paul Fox took to the Radio Times to explain just how it would all – hopefully – come together, promising that “all the items that used to appear here and there on Saturday afternoons will now come under the Grandstand umbrella”.

    With Dimmock at the controls from a swanky new studio at Lime Grove, at least for those first few weeks before his co-anchor – a tyro David Coleman – took sole charge of presentation (allowing Dimmock to move behind the scenes), there were football newsflashes, racing updates (complete with the latest odds), and updates from reporters all around the UK. Fox promised that “sports news of the day will be given as it happens – and, whenever possible, where it happens”, thanks to that BBC Outside Broadcast unit. There was the promise of live horse racing each week, live swimming, motor racing, ice skating and table tennis in the coming weeks. Some of those admittedly easier to capture on camera than others.

    There was even the tentative promise of (“if our hopes are realised”) live boxing. But, slightly surprisingly, the callout event on the big preview of Grandstand was… snooker. Not the most obvious draw for the black and white tellies of the time, but this was no ordinary event – Joe Davis, the “greatest snooker player of all time” had signed up for a series of special challenge matches at venues around Britain, taking on top players of the day, such as Walter Donaldson and John Pulman. And, to make it even more of an occasion, Joe’s first match would be against brother and fellow pro Fred Davis.

    The action wasn’t just restricted to That England, either. The BBC’s Scottish Outside Broadcast Unit (a branding that conjures up a certain stereotypical image, unless it’s just me picturing an OB van bedecked in tartan) would be on hand to capture action from the World Amateur Team Golf Championship from St Andrews.

    It’s fair to say that was a lot to be going on with. The only real hitch was a TV schedule that insisted subsequent children’s programming start airing at 4.45pm, a time which neatly clashes with all the sports results Grandstand would really quite like to tell viewers about. It took until April 1959 before those fifteen critical minutes were finally added to Grandstand’s runtime, allowing for a full Sports Result Service, and an easier route for participants in the football pools to learn they’d need to work for at least another week.

    As mentioned, the whole affair being centred around the Outside Broadcast Unit rather than sport specifically gave the programme freedom to wander from its core remit if circumstances required, such as the Henley Regatta or sundry Car Shows. A prime example of this came on 22 February 1964, and an edition promising “the return of the Beatles to the UK, as well as horse racing and rugby union”.

    “Ringo! Ringo! Have you heard? Clyde vs Cowdenbeath was postponed!”

    Unsurprisingly given its position on this list, the programme was a success. So much so, the Grandstand branding swiftly swallowed up key events on the sporting calendar. Alongside regular Saturday afternoon Grandstand, the Radio Times would trumpet the presence of Derby Day Grandstand (from 1960), Cup Final Grandstand (from 1965), World Cup Grandstand (from 1966), Olympic Grandstand (from 1968), and Ryder Cup Grandstand (from 1993), many of which didn’t even air at the weekend. The slow creep of sporting endeavours into the Sabbath also led to occasional airings of Sunday Grandstand from 1967 onwards.

    It wasn’t until May 1981 that Sunday Grandstand became a regular fixture, a switch to BBC2 providing the freedom to stretch into the evening schedule.

    However, the most thrillingly-titled variant was set to arrive on the evening of Tuesday 21 April 1970, where a special edition (step aside, Sportsnight) featured the big Joe Bugner v Ray Patterson boxing match in London, followed by “Apollo 13 Splashdown”. Yep, the return to Earth of moon men James A. Lovell Jr, John L. Swigert Jr and Fred W. Haise Jr led to the programme being rechristened Splashdown Grandstand for a single edition. Just look at this planned programme schedule for the night:

    8.0 International Professional Boxing: Joe Bugner v Ray Patterson
    8.45 The Main News With Kenneth Kendall
    9.0 Apollo 13 Splashdown
    9.02 Re-entry due
    9.11 Parachutes open
    9.16 Splashdown
    10.10 On Deck
    10.15 International Match of the Day: England v Northern Ireland

    Epic. Except, of course, a set of fuel cells 180,000 nautical miles from Earth had other ideas. The return flight of the Apollo 13 crew had to be frantically rearranged for the previous Friday, and one of the most exhilarating live broadcasts of the entire space race took place then instead.

    Daily Mail, Fri 17 April 1970
    Daily Mirror, Fri 17 April 1970: The Real Splashdown Schedule

    All very well, but what of our Splashdown Grandstand? Those midweek sporting events instead went out as individual programmes, with the scheduled Splashdown programme replaced by The Dick Emery Show and a rescheduled 24 Hours. Ah, well.

    Rewinding slightly, by 1965 Grandstand had a rival on the other side. ITV’s initial reticence to sport receding to make way for World of Sport, which was now very much in play. But while their rival had the winsome Dickie “Last Time I Saw Something Like That The Whole Herd Had To Be Put Down” Davies at the helm, the BBC still held the rights to all the key events, and with Frank Bough sharing hosting duties with David Coleman (the latter frequently off displaying his commentary chops), there was still only one destination for the serious sports fan. World of Sport had Canadian log rolling, Grandstand had Eddie Waring, Football Focus and the Vidiprinter. It was no contest. Especially as Grandstand would be the go to destination for getting those all-important results come 4.45pm. Even now, people of a certain age can only read the Classified Football Results with a particular intonation in their heads.

    By the 1980s, a bejumpered Coleman was more at home behind a Question of Sport desk, and with Frank Bough occupied in a similarly wooly vocation on Breakfast Time, it was time for TV’s Mr Unflappability to shine. Step forward Des Lynam. Never had helming several hours of live television on a weekly basis – imagine an election night every seven days, basically – seemed so ruddy effortless. And so, by the late 1980s, Grandstand was cock of the walk. World of Sport had ceased to be, with ITV spending more energy on snaffling exclusivity on individual sporting events – think The Football League, Athletics and Horse Racing – but Grandstand’s greatest foe, and ultimate conqueror, was about to appear from the Sky.

    The early days of satellite broadcasting had been no threat to the main broadcasters – nobody was breaking into a sweat over the Screensport Super Cup – but by the mid-1990s, Sky Sports had the budget and the broadcasting bandwidth to do everything Grandstand couldn’t. It could continue live coverage of golfing tournaments, rugby matches or tennis opens way into primetime, with no pressing need to halt coverage in favour of Steve Wright’s People Show or Big Break. And as the pot of available events began to empty, the BBC needed to make more of what it still had. Would people be tuning into Grandstand and hope they enjoyed what they found there, or would they be more enticed by a programme listing for a live Six Nations match?

    In the digital EPG age of the noughties, viewers didn’t want to just see that a sprawling Grandstand strand was on, they’d want to know which sport to expect and when. A brand that was once spread across the BBC like sporting butter seemed to be little more than an anachronism kept around out of loyalty more than practicality, and in January 2007 it finally bowed out. By the time of the final Grandstand programme listing, pointing viewers toward the Red Button and BBC website for uninterrupted coverage of the Australian Open or European Figure Skating Championships was the norm, it was clear how the linear Grandstand strand wasn’t really needed any more. The fact that much of that final Saturday edition was shovelled onto BBC2 to make way for a live FA Cup Match of the Day between Luton Town and Blackburn only underlined how inessential the once hardy old brand had become.

    Then, it was gone. Broken up for scrap. The following Saturday saw Football Focus officially span off as a standalone programme (which, as far at Electronic Programme Guides had been concerned, it had been for a while anyway), as was the BBC’s Six Nations Rugby coverage. Final Score had the same treatment, once an integral part of Grandstand, now a plucky stat-based orphan left to flourish on its own.

    And do you know what? It was fine. When there wasn’t any big sporting event to show on a Saturday afternoon, the BBC no longer felt the need to fling on something sporty for the sake of it. This was an era where Sky Plus was king of the living room. People wanted to be able to record ‘Rugby League’, ‘Swimming’, or ‘Golf’, not use up a valuable chunk of their PVR’s 20GB capacity on several whole hours of sport because that’s how the programme guide had wanted it.

    This was the future.

    And yet, in a way, it was 1958 all over again.

    NOTE: Updated figure and table on 16/7/23 to correct the episode counts for 1965 and 1966, plus totals, accordingly. Thanks to eagle-eyed reader @michael_sas for spotting the discrepancy.


    There we go, another one out of the way. Phew. Next time: we brush the quivering brim of the Top Ten. Ooh, eh?

    Of course, a photo of 70s Des is enough to send anyone’s brim a-quivering.
  • Paging Dr Clitterhouse! It’s The 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (16 and 15)

    Paging Dr Clitterhouse! It’s The 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (16 and 15)

    “We interrupt this programme to bring you a football game.”


    16: Match of the Day

    (Shown 4055 times, 1964-2021)

    Well, here’s one that was always going to appear, and one where I probably need to clarify the criteria for inclusion. In general with this list, where something had specific programme branding applied to it and it keeps to the core format of the programme, I’m counting it. So, Nationwide Election Special counts, Tweenies Songtime doesn’t. Postman Pat Special Delivery Service please step forward, This Morning With Anne and Nick’s Live Autopsy Hour not so fast.

    That gets a little more complicated with Match of the Day. For one thing, the first eleven times the title ‘Match of the Day’ appeared in TV listings, it had absolutely nothing to do with football. While MOTD as we’d come to know it first aired on Saturday 22 August 1964, Match of the Day first appeared as a programme title a whole two months earlier. A total of eleven editions of ‘Match of the Day’ aired in relation to the Wimbledon Lawn Tennis Championships in 1964 before the moniker was first applied to kickball.

    The MOTD branding would go on to become closely aligned to both football and (during Wimbledon fortnight) tennis highlights, with the latter sometimes made clear in the programme title (as Match of the Day from Wimbledon or Wimbledon [YEAR] Match of the Day), but sometimes not.

    The other complication comes in defining what makes up the ‘core’ MOTD experience. Saturday night football highlights are the main thing you’d associate the brand with, but it’s also been used for live football coverage (sometimes as Match of the Day Live, International Match of the Day or Match of the Day: The Road to Wembley, sometimes as just plain old Match of the Day). And what about Match of the Day 2? Does that count? How about Match of the Day Greats, or …Kickabout, or …Top 10? How about lockdown gap-filler Match of Their Day?

    Right, to try and get some kind of vaguely accurate figure here, I’m going to go with the following rule: If it’s tagged as Match of the Day, and the bulk of the content is footage from a football match (or matches, either live or highlights) of a contemporary match, it counts. If it’s not one of those things (so, Kickabout et al), or doesn’t have the MOTD branding, it doesn’t count. Settled? Good.

    The waters are, of course, further muddied by the MOTD branding not always being used in programme listings. Since 2014, much of the BBC’s live or highlight coverage of The FA Cup has been billed as ‘The FA Cup’, keeping it away from the (now) more Premier League-focused MOTD name. Which means that, in this age of iPlayer and rights issues, the two sets of highlights are now kept in separate containers. Even when they’re next to each other in the schedule.

    How much better would this be if it had involved Gary Lineker walking across the studio floor to a different desk at 11pm? Like Stephen Fry walking away from the DEF II desk to wheel in the Babylon 2 set in the first ever edition of DEF II?

    The title World Cup Match of the Day was used when nightly highlights round-ups were broadcast in 1974 (live matches then going out as World Cup Grandstand). Then that title lay dormant for 15 years, with the programme title reused for highlights of Italia ’90 qualifiers in 1989, provided they were on a Saturday – midweek qualifier highlights went out as part of Sportsnight. That is until October 1989, when World Cup Match of the Day was used for a live (midweek) broadcast of the Poland v England qualifier. Then, the programme title hibernated until the 2006 World Cup in Germany, except for the highlights packages for Euro 2000 that used “MotD at Euro 2000” but not for the live matches… look, here’s a table of RT billing titles for every major international football tournament since 1950. Titles included in MotD’s episode count are in bold.

    Yes, “A European Sporting Event” for the 1960 final. Very grandiose.

    Anyway, let’s rewind a bit. Football on the BBC has gone out under a variety of guises – hey, here’s another largely pointless table, this time of non-MotD football match billings in the Radio Times:

    The entry for ‘Football’ up there is a bit tenuous, admittedly. The next time just ‘Football’ was used as a programme billing was in 1984, for coverage of the The Courage Soccer Six from Birmingham, so mentally insert that in place if you prefer.

    So, it’s probably for the best that they settled on another programme title. The above isn’t even a comprehensive list – between 1971 and 1997, the Sportsnight Special branding was used for midweek football matches, mostly but not exclusively for those broadcast live (first: FA Cup Third Round Replay highlights, last: live coverage of AS Monaco v Newcastle United in the UEFA Cup).

    The BBC’s first televised association with Association (Football) dates all the way back to September 1937. That inaugural coverage was, as you may well already be aware, a thrilling tussle between Arsenal and… Arsenal Reserves at Highbury. Yep, fifteen minutes of a training match. While this could easily have been some filmed footage flung out as part of Newsreel, the BBC didn’t take that easier option. The Beeb’s brand new mobile television unit travelled to Highbury to broadcast the footage live. The first ever billed football match (as shown below) was indeed “a demonstration by the members of the Arsenal team” on 16 September 1937, but live footage of football first went out a day earlier – two minutes of soundless but live footage of the Arsenal team went out at 3.45pm the previous day, as part of magazine series Picture Page.

    Such was the cost of sending the mobile television unit (around £35, or the price of a pie at Wembley in 2023), a series of broadcasts from the ground were requested to make the whole affair a little more cost effective. As a result, a total of three transmissions were made from the ground, plus (following that brief initial broadcast on Picture Page) a test transmission of Arsenal Reserves versus Millwall Reserves was beamed back to a special viewing room at Ally Pally, so BBC bosses could gauge how suitable this football lark was for public consumption.

    The second billed visit to The Arsenal occurred on 17 September that year, which led to another broadcasting first: George Male becoming the first footballer ever to be interviewed on live television. On being questioned about the diversity within the Highbury playing staff, Male proudly proclaimed “they are from Scotland, Yorkshire, Wales, all over the place… provided they are British subjects. We couldn’t put a foreigner in the team”. Plus ca change, eh? As a result (of the broadcast, not Male’s xenophobia), the BBC would go on to broadcast the FA Cup Final between Preston North End and Huddersfield in 1938, followed a year later with the Portsmouth versus Wolves final – the latter listed alongside the caveat “unless anything untoward happens” in the Radio Times (and a warning that “no rediffusion in places of public entertainment will be permitted”).

    Following the war, the BBC were keen to show more live football for the demobbed masses, but there was a problem. The Football League – gatekeepers for the bulk of English professional matches – were dead against the idea, calculating that allowing the still-small television audience to watch coverage on tiny monochrome sets would be preferred to the full-3D, full-colour, full-Bovril matchday experience, and stop attending matches in person. Luckily for the BBC, the FA in general were more receptive to the broadcaster. Less luckily for the BBC, technology at the time limited them to covering events within a 20-mile radius of Alexander Palace.

    As a result, the next televised football match, taking place on Saturday 19 October 1946, was from the lofty heights of the Athenian Football League, with Amateur Cup holders Barnet entertaining Wealdstone. Even then, the broadcast was far from simple – the permission of a local resident had to be sought so BBC engineers could borrow their phone line, and from another resident to plonk some scaffolding for cameras on their allotment. Thus the programme budget was duly increased to include compensation for damaged crops.

    That wasn’t the end of the technical hitches. Despite the promise of “part of the first half and the whole of the second half” in the Radio Times, bad light ultimately curtailed the live broadcast fifteen minutes from the end of the match.

    At least anyone watching from those houses in the background could just have looked out of their window.

    Despite those obstacles, the broadcast was deemed a success, and the BBC would go on to broadcast further (non-Football League) matches from the London area.

    By 1954, the popularity of television had grown, along with the demand for televised sport. As a result, Head of Sport Peter Dimmock along with Paul Fox devised Sportsview, the BBC’s first midweek sporting magazine programme. This offered football match highlights alongside other sports, and soon became must-see viewing for sport fans lucky enough to own a television receiver. That popularity led to Sports Special, a Saturday night spin-off for the series packing a more football-focused remit, with Peter Dimmock taking to the Radio Times to provide exciting details on how “a helicopter, two aeroplanes, plus a fleet of motor-cycles and fast cars” would be employed to rush filmed reports from stadia to studio each week.

    Radio Times Issue 1660, 4 Sep 1955 – 10 Sep 1955

    Sports Special would go on to run for ten years from 1955, accompanied in October 1958 by Saturday afternoon stablemate Grandstand. However, the very march of progress that made the programme possible in the first place (including, of course, the thrilling assistance of fast cars and helicopters and possibly at least one Milk Tray Man) would lead to its downfall. Match reports being shot on 16mm film meant that on arrival at the studio, footage first had to be processed, returned as wet negatives and frantically edited at Lime Grove by harried editors praying that they’d get the job done in time for transmission. The reliance on filmed reports (and the budget only allowing for a single camera at each match) also carried the risk of a crucial goal being slammed home while the camera operator was changing reels.

    Videotape and multi-camera coverage were still only on the horizon, but Sports Special’s days were numbered. What was once a regular weekly treat became a more sporadic offering, and despite rebranding for most weeks as Football Special from late 1961, in April 1965 the programme would air as a Saturday night strand for the last time, by now on the rechristened BBC-1, with a broadcast of that day’s England v Scotland match from Wembley.

    But! Hope for football fans was not lost. Over on upstart BBC-2, a new programme had arrived in 1964, opening with the classic Wolstenholme words “Welcome to Match of the Day, the first of a weekly series coming to you every Saturday on BBC-2. As you can hear, we’re in Beatleville for this Liverpool versus Arsenal match”, and ending with a score of 3-2 to the Mighty Reds.

    It would go on to become quite popular.

    The write-up for that first-ever episode in the Radio Times went as follows:

    Today for the first time soccer fans can watch a feature-length version – as opposed to a potted ‘highlights’ version — of a regular League fixture. Which one? That, by agreement with the Football League, remains a secret until 4.0 this afternoon. But Bryan Cowgill, BBC-tv’s sports chief, promises that it will be a top match.

    The agreement by which BBC-tv won permission for this came after careful negotiations between Bryan Cowgill and League Secretary Alan Hardaker. It allows for fifty-five minutes of coverage, enough to show the whole development of the game, and for its screening at a more popular hour.

    Up to now we have only been able to show ten-minute edited films of any given match. which, effectively meant a machine-gun succession of goal-goal-goal,’ says Cowgill. ‘Now we can fall in line With BBC-2’s policy by offering “depth” treatment of our most popular sport’. To those who think this breakthrough is a further blow to turnstile takings, he offers his experienced opinion that ‘television never kept anyone away from the best in sport.’

    In charge of the new venture as producer is Alan Chivers, BBC-tv’s most experienced soccer specialist. He intends to make full use of the technical advantages of 625 lines, and says: ‘We’re no longer restricted mainly to the close-up, With 625’s greater definition we can use wider shots without losing clarity, and so show much more of the overall pattern of a game.’

    Radio Times Issue 2128, 20-26 August 1964

    Following the 1966 World Cup, famously won by A British Team Wearing Red (haven’t checked, I presume it was Wales), MOTD made the move from BBC-2 to BBC-1 for the 1966/67 season. Although the programme would move back to BBC-2 for a week in November 1968 so that the first colour edition of the series could be shown. Any football fanatics without a 625-line set that week at least got to watch Hitchcock’s Anatomy of a Murder on BBC1 that night. It wouldn’t be until 15 November 1969 that colour MOTD first arrived on BBC-1 – on the channel’s first official day of colour TV.

    If you’re wondering, the first colour programme in the listings for that day: The Weather.

    Transition to colour TV aside, the core remit of the series – football highlights on a Saturday night – remained unchanged for a long time. Even when events called for a special episode of MOTD, it was usually affixed to standard match highlights, as had been the case on 10 Jan 1970 and the excitingly-billed “Match of the Day Special: 1970 World Cup Draw“. This contained the exciting curveball of having David Coleman reporting from Mexico City’s Maria Isabella Hotel, where the 16 qualifying nations discovered who they’d be playing that summer (“Presented by Telesistema Mexicano”, no less). Even then, as befitting the programme, the bulk of the content that week was still of match highlights from a suitably sodden football ground.

    A year before that Mexican jamboree, MOTD had added the first ever slow-motion replays to their coverage, an innovation that would make a huge difference to the way football was covered. And those innovations were increasingly important. At a time when the USA and USSR were in a PR war to get the first boots on the moon, BBC and ITV’s respective football flagships were locked in a similar, if slightly less cosmic, battle.

    The nature of ITV meant there was no network-wide football highlights programme – the whole story of football on ITV could fill an entry on its own – but the big hitter was undoubtedly LWT’s The Big Match, which tried to add a little Light Entertainment pizazz to the whole affair (oh, okay. Brian Moore and a desk with a phone on it). The battle ultimately became so intense that Michael Grade led a coup to snaffle up exclusive rights to the Football League in 1978, the move was famously reported in the papes as ‘Snatch of the Day‘. Which would have been quite witty had the pun not already been public knowledge since a 1974 anti-pickpocket public information film. Luckily, the Office of Fair Trading put a stop to that nonsense, and Match of the Day was safe. For a while.

    The battle of the broadcasters intensified throughout the next few years, though there was a truce of sorts after the channels agreed to alternate ownership of the prime Saturday night highlights slot, meaning MOTD aired on Sunday afternoons throughout the 1980/81 and 1982/83 seasons. However, for 1983/84 there was a new, long-awaited change for both channels: live coverage of Football League matches. It’s almost strange to imagine such a thing at a time when almost every single match in the top five tiers of English football can (legally) be watched live, but that represented the first time live league football would be shown on TV since 1960. Highlights briefly faded into the background. Especially during the start of the 1985/86 season, when disputes over money meant TV was a football-free zone for several months. At least that led to Saint & Greavsie parading West Ham’s leading goalscorer Frank McAvennie around London to see if anyone would recognise him, which is quite fun.

    1988 saw a dramatic change to coverage for the Beeb, with ITV paying a (then-)whopping fee for exclusivity. It certainly seems quaint now, but paying £44m for 21 live matches per season was big news at the time, not least as it restricted MOTD to coverage of the FA Cup (and for the most part, a rebranding to Match of the Day: The Road to Wembley).

    As football’s post-1990 popularity soared Skywards (insert a Waddle penalty gag here if you must) even bigger changes were afoot. But then you probably already know all about that. At least that meant top division highlights returned to the BBC.

    And – if we all pretend those few years of Andy Townsend’s Tactics Truck et al were just a national hallucination – that’s where they’ve stayed ever since. And indeed, the lockdown-era Project Restart even led to the return of Live Top Tier Football to BBC1 after a gap of 32 years.

    The mission statement of the programme has certainly changed a lot since Kenneth Wolstenholme’s original trip to Beatleville. The very thing original producer Bryan Cowgill was so happy to be leaving behind – “ten-minute edited films of any given match” – is now the core product of the programme. But, in a world where watching live football on TV is largely restricted to those with a disposable incomes or an illicit IPTV hookup, it’s still appointment television for many, and for everyone else it’s just nice to know it’s still there.

    After all, we’ve now seen a vision of the future without Match of the Day. It wasn’t pretty.

    NOTE: If you’d like to read a lot more about the history of football on British TV, be sure to take in Steve Williams’ superb Goalmouths over on OffTheTelly.


    15: Doctors

    (Shown 4081 times, 2000-2021)

    For a genre of television that has seemed utterly omnipresent since the days of Stooky Bill, it’s actually a little surprising to learn that medical drama series were few and far between in the early days of British television. In the early days of the BBC Television Service, the closest you were likely to get was seeing a concert by someone who’d left the medical profession for the world of music, such as pianist Leslie ‘Hutch’ Hutchinson (5 Dec 1936, Starlight) or Norman Hackforth (4 Feb 1937, The Composer at the Piano).

    As was the style at the time, there would occasionally be serious factual programming based on medical matters, especially in the post-war years, such as 1947’s I Want to be a Doctor, but dramatic fiction from within doctorly settings were a feature that television simply didn’t seem to fancy. It’s tempting to suggest that the medical profession was deemed sacrosanct when it to TV’s myopic gaze, but that’s swiftly disproved by there being a smattering of comedy plays about the profession. May 1947 saw Annette Mills’ comedy feature Rotten Row, where a dilapidated row of horse boxes is converted into a fracture unit next to an evacuated hospital in post-war London (I repeat: a comedy), while August that year saw the screening of The Amazing Dr Clitterhouse, a comedy thriller by Barre Lyndon.

    See, it wasn’t just me having a fever dream.

    By the late 1940s Britain finally had a National Health Service, so it’s perhaps understandable that television preferred to spend airtime demystifying what went on behind hospital doors. As a result, factual programmes often made an appearance in the Radio Times, such as 1948’s Mass Radiography, (“The Medical Officer in charge of a Mobile X-Ray Unit belonging to the North-West London Regional Hospital Board demonstrates a new technique of diagnosing chest diseases in their-early stages”), or 1949’s medical documentary series Matters of Life and Death (“Episode 7: Dr. F. Avery Jones and Mr. Norman Tanner, a physician and surgeon who have made a special study of gastric and duodenal ulcers, discuss their prevalence and show how they are diagnosed and treated”). All very worthwhile, but hardly using matters medical to offer a sense of escapism for the TV audience.

    That changed in 1951, with a six-part television adaptation of Anthony Trollope’s 1855 book The Warden. The first of the Chronicles of Barsetshire series, the book followed the fortunes of Mr Septimus Harding, an elderly warden from Barsetshire-based Hiram’s Hospital. That offering aside, it took the launch of ITV in 1955 to successfully transplant the notion of a medical TV drama into Britain’s cathode-ray tubes. Emergency Ward 10 (ATV, 1957-67) became one of the nascent network’s breakout hits, albeit one that came about due to a misunderstanding. It had been suggested to programme creator Tessa Diamond that a show about daily hospital life might be a hit. It was only after Ward 10 was created that her agent revealed the original suggestion was actually for a documentary series.

    Daily Mirror, Tuesday,  Feb. 19, 1957

    Once that happy accident was out of the way, the programme quickly became a success. So much so, in ten years on the air it clocked up a total of 1,016 episodes – including in 1964 one that featured an early example of an inter-racial kiss between two actors.

    Aside: For a spell, it seems to have been considered television’s first-ever such embrace (coming a full four years before the Star Trek episode “Plato’s Stepchildren”). However, it was actually preceded by both Granada’s 1962 Play of the Week In Your Small Corner, and 1959 ABC Armchair Theatre play Hot Summer Night – both plays featuring Jamaican actor Lloyd Reckord.

    An inter-racial relationship being portrayed in a 1959 TV drama? Very progressive. Only billing the three white actors in the newspaper adverts for it? Not so much.

    Anyway, with Ward 10 proving a success, other medical soap operas would later appear in an attempt to rebottle that magic, such as General Hospital (ATV, 1972-79), Angels (BBC, 1975-83) and Children’s Ward (Children’s ITV, 1989-2000). On top of that, daytime TV found plenty of room for antipodean imports The Young Doctors (Nine Network 1976–1983, airing on ITV from 1982 and Sky Channel from 1989), A Country Practice (Seven, 1981–1994, shown on ITV from 1982 and Sky Channel – in primetime! – from 1984) and Shortland Street (TVNZ 2, 1992–, shown on ITV from 1993).

    For those of a certain age, the above image will be closely associated with being off sick from school.

    As the millennium (and to a lesser extent, the Willennium) neared, the previously-listed Holby City (BBC, 1999-2022) started a residency on BBC1. And, with that proving popular enough for BBC bosses to attempt a daytime version, this was followed a year later by the first episode of… Doctors. Yes, we’ve got to it at last. Phew.

    Set in the fictional Midlands town of Letherbridge, the Chris Murray-devised programme follows events within the local doctor’s surgery and the nearby university campus surgery, along with those of the stakeholders within.

    Commissioning a brand-new scripted drama to go out in the pre-news slot 12.30pm each weekday – a place you’d usually expect to contain an episode of Changing Rooms, Celebrity Ready Steady Cook or Bargain Hunt – was certainly a brave move by BBC head of daytime programming Jane Lush. To remain receptive to occasional viewers, the programme was to use self-contained stories featuring the key cast rather than having long-running plot strands (a la imperial phase The Bill). In addition, casting cosy drama series stalwart Christopher Timothy as key character Mac McGuire certainly wasn’t going to hurt.

    To introduce viewers to the series, the opening episode aired in a primetime-adjacent slot of 6:35pm on Sunday 26 March 2000, with the first regular daytime episode airing the following lunchtime. Under the auspices of showrunner Mal Young, whose vintage included Holby City, Casualty and would later cross the Atlantic to exec produce The Young and the Restless, Doctors proved successful enough to be tried out in a 7pm weekday slot in the summer of 2000. However, it quickly became obvious that a rival soap wasn’t much of a threat to the Emmerdale behemoth, and it returned to the cosier confines of 12.30pm.

    And that happy little niche was where it would stay for just over a year and a half, before shifting to a 2.10pm slot in November 2001 in a soapy double-bill with Neighbours. And that was where it stays for several years, Letherbridge being happily twinned with Erinsborough five days per week, making it a Doctors appointment you weren’t likely to miss (oh shut up).

    However, in 2007 calamity struck. With the FremantleMedia demanding a whopping £300m from the BBC in return for the rights to Neighbours for the next eight years, the flagship show was instead set to move to Channel Five. The result: a major soap-shaped hole in BBC1’s daytime schedule. What was the BBC to do? Splurge a chunk of programme budget on nabbing the rights to Shortland Street? Fling on repeats of The Sullivans? Nope, by that point Doctors was doing well enough for it to be promoted into that key post-news slot, with the remaining episodes of Neighbours switching to its post-2pm slot.

    Doctors continued to perform admirably for the lunchtime audience, but finding a companion for it proved a little more tricky. US drama show Monk was tried out in that slot during December 2007, before long the Neighbours burn-off episodes were restored to the slot while packing its bags and preparing for life on Five. Diagnosis Murder was given a run in that slot a few months later, but April 2008 saw the launch of the BBC’s new secret weapon: Out of the Blue. It was cool. It was sexy. It could air five days per week. And most importantly, it was Australian.

    Set in the fashionable Sydney beach suburb of Manly, the action started with a group of thirty-year-old friends returning home for a high school reunion, only for the reunion to end in murder and an investigation into which of them done it. It couldn’t fail. And crucially, it had actually been commissioned by the BBC, so could be tailored to meet the needs and wants of a British audience.

    Obviously, it failed. Big time. Ratings were so unspectacular, it was nudged over to BBC2 after just fourteen episodes on BBC1, and lasted less than a year before being cancelled entirely. Not to worry though, Five picked up the repeat rights to the series, and put them out on digital offshoot Fiver. I’m assuming for a much lesser outlay than they’d paid for Neighbours. Diagnosis Murder picked up the post-Doctors reins, and proved a much more popular companion. After all, it is the 62nd most-broadcast programme on the BBC of all time.

    Speaking of Doctors (which is what we’re supposed to be doing here, of course), it was the bedrock of the BBC daytime schedule. By 2010, it was picking up a comfortable two million viewers per episode, regularly winning the daytime ratings war. Indeed, some episodes even rated as high as 3.5 million viewers, numbers that EastEnders producers would probably throttle Wellard for nowadays.

    And as time went on, those viewing figures only continued to grow. By 2017, they were sitting at a comfortable 2.5 million per episode, at one point reaching a peak of four million (according to a Telegraph link I’m not going to pay to read, so we’ll take Google’s word for it).

    Now, as will be abundantly clear from this update, I’ve barely ever watched an episode of Doctors. However, what has become clear to me is that the creative team behind it aren’t afraid not to try something thrillingly different from time to time. The most obvious example of this would be superbly titled episode “The Joe Pasquale Problem“, which involved a patient seeing everyone as Joe Pasquale (special guest for that episode: Joe Pasq… oh, you’ve guessed).

    Better still, an episode airing on the telltale date of 31 October 2014 saw character Al “forced to confront his scepticism of the supernatural when he finds a whistle with mysterious powers”. Or, if you prefer, an episode of a daytime soap opera was used as an excuse to put on a production of M R James’ 1904 ghost story Oh, Whistle, and I’ll Come to You, My Lad. You don’t get that with Emmerdale, do you?

    That’s the only episode of Doctors I’ve ever watched, and not going to lie – it was great. The modest budget of a soap episode really helped it capture at least a soupçon of the 1970s aesthetic of the original A Ghost Story for Christmas, which is handy as Jonathan Miller’s 1968 version of the same was a decidedly different beast from the annual anthologies it begat. That Doctors episode is on DailyMotion if you fancy seeing it. And so are plenty more, if you like the sound of the series and would like to catch up.

    (By the time you finish that, I might have the next entry on the list written.)


    That’s another one in the bag, which isn’t a literal bag. More ‘soon’, if I get out the habit of spending an hour researching something for the sake of a single sentence about something not really connected to the programme I’m meant to be talking about.

  • Wake Up Mario! It’s the 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (20 and 19)

    Wake Up Mario! It’s the 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (20 and 19)

    Here we go. Top twenty. Big leagues. Every programme from this point on an absolute titan of British broadcasting. Starting with…


    20: Working Lunch

    (Shown 3296 times, 1994-2010)

    I’m willing to admit, this is a bit of a surprise.

    For a programme that would go on to become the 20th most-broadcast programme in the BBC’s history (under the conditions laid out for the purposes of this list), it’s probably fair to say it was a little undersold in the Radio Times for the week of Working Lunch’s first-ever broadcast on Monday 19 September 1994. “A daily look at business and how it affects us.” That’s it. Publish. Done. To be fair, they did have the write-up for ‘1:00pm History File: The World Since 1945’ to crack on with. That one probably needed a bit more research.

    So, that tiny informational morsel aside, what was Working Lunch? A cookery show? A documentary exploring the catering industry? William S. Burroughs’ surprisingly tame follow-up to Naked Lunch? Nope, it was – and I appreciate this makes it sounds much worse than it is – a weekdaily topical programme covering business, consumer and personal finance news, the twist being that it was all done in a relatably accessible manner.

    Oh dear? No, dear. It certainly helped that the programme was captained by Adam Shaw and early-era Adrian Chiles (coming off the back of hosting Radio 4’s Financial World Tonight), who offered a clear contrast to the Beeb’s other business output, such as World Business Report or Business Edition. This was much a looser affair, where every day is Casual Friday and there aren’t many meetings and someone has brought cakes from home. Look, here’s a bit where Adrian Chiles is playing Super Mario 64.

    GET BACK TO WORK, CHILES.

    Despite it having been originally planned as a vehicle for Jill Dando and George Alagiah, Chiles was considered to have been a boon for the new series, his Black Country burr certainly a lot more welcoming than what you’d expect from your average BBC financial programme. Aside from that, Working Lunch was the first live programme on the Beeb to rely on a virtual set, which certainly helped disguise the fact it was being recorded in the pokiest studio the News and Current Affairs department had to offer. While BBC News had been using a virtual set for opening and closing long shots at the time, close-ups and mid-shots employed an actual set with real furniture. With ‘Lunch, not even the desks were real. Heck, if mid-90s CGI had been up to the task, one wonders if we’d still have had the meatspace version of Adrian Chiles.

    One illustrative if surprising signifier of how well-received the programme was become happened in February 1996. Chiles found himself at Heathrow Airport in the midst of screaming teenagers. Not there for him, of course (let’s not go crazy here), they were present as 90s popmonger Robbie Williams was due to arrive at the airport en route to some foreign clime. After working his way through the crowd and onto an escalator toward the departure lounge, the West Bromwich wag was tapped on the shoulder by none other than Williams himself, who took the opportunity to express his enjoyment of Working Lunch. See, he’s not all bad. That almost makes up for Swing When You’re Winning. Almost.

    Those early years even offered up a fun little title sequence, where a goldfish finds some gold coins and tries to put them in a bank, only to get chased away by a shark. Granted, it didn’t hold a candle to the Westminster crocodile of On The Record, but this was only weekday daytime BBC2, expectations should be lowered accordingly.

    That was replaced a few years later by an even more comic opening sequence to mark the shift to widescreen programming in 1998, with the goldfish and shark careering around a tremendously 90s CGI set. This is certainly not a scene you’d expect from the titles to a daily business news roundup.

    For anyone wanting to know, the CGI goldfish is called Lloyd. And for anyone who wants to feel a bit sad, the real Lloyd died the week this new title sequence aired for the first time. Until that point however, he’d lived in a fishtank made out of a vintage 50s television, thereby making him Britain’s Coolest Goldfish. So, a life well-lived.

    Bye, Lloyd.

    In later life, Declan Curry and future Breakfast host Naga Munchetty would join the series, but despite a revamp in 2008 that threw in things like a ‘Tech Shed’ to test out the latest gadgets, it seems the strand just wasn’t the cult hit it once was, and in 2010 the programme aired for the last time.

    To be fair, if an episode where Terry Wogan gives a web surfing masterclass isn’t bringing in the viewers, the jig is probably up.


    19: Panorama

    (Shown 3346 times, 1953-2021)

    What am I supposed to tell the Panorama audience?

    Let the strident tones of Francis Lai’s Aujourd’hui C’est Toi soundtrack a spinning globe, and let a nation of kids ask if they can put another channel on.

    (Aside: of course, the best use of the Panorama title sequence came in Dave Allen’s 1990 stand-up series for BBC1, which came with no sketches, no opening theme, no title sequence or even anything showing the programme’s title. That was apart from episode three of the series, which used the opening titles for Panorama, with Allen claiming “we can’t afford any titles of our own, so we borrowed some”.)

    At the time of writing (the year 2023, which makes it increasingly embarrassing this list only covers up to the end of 2021, but shush), Panorama is but months away from clocking up seventy years on British screens, the first ever episode arriving in November 1953. And, while much of Panorama has been of the cracker-dry variety, the Radio Times box-out for that first ever episode really goes gangbusters on the whole austerity aesthetic, with original host (or ‘guide’) Patrick Murphy staring you out in a way that would make you leave a pub immediately.

    “I’m going home. Tap on the window when I’m in the car park if he starts trying to follow me, so I can start running.”

    Originally airing on a fortnightly basis, those original reflections of the contemporary scene did at least include a tantalising “telecartoon of passing events”, which is surely now making you think of The Day Today’s Brant. In short, those very early years were a markedly different beast from the Panorama the nation would become used to in later years, being more of a magazine programme looking at the arts as much as current affairs, but it would soon evolve. In the case of the host, evolve very quickly, with initial host Patrick Murphy replaced in the second edition by Max Robertson.

    For the first couple of years, the ‘Rama initially aired every other Wednesday evening, usually between 9pm and 10pm, but from September 1955 changes were afoot. The programme moved to Monday evenings, it moved to an earlier slot around 8pm, and it would become a weekly programme. On top of that, the programme’s tagline was changed to “Television’s Window on the World”. Indeed, the changes were outlined in an accompanying Radio Times article, which promised to comment on world affairs as much as home-based happenings, with co-producer Michael Peacock promising everything from “ships, jazz, people, ploughing, theatre, industry, art, books, buildings or bulldozers”.

    To try and take that range of topics, Panorama was afforded access to all the BBC’s resources: outside broadcast cameras, film camera teams, Roving Eye cameras and use of the shiny new Eurovision link to provide live broadcasts from across Europe. While new host Richard Dimbleby would be keeping track of everything from the studio, Max Robertson wasn’t cast aside, but rather given a roving assignment with the outside units, while Malcolm Muggeridge was afforded a similarly roving remit as ‘entrepreneur for theatre, films, music and the arts’.

    The choice of Dimbleby Sr as Panorama’s new guide proved to be an inspired one, pretty much forging a template for the current affairs presenter, offering a perfect blend of gravitas, insight, interview skills and background research. Little wonder that he would be chosen to helm BBC TV’s first ever foray into live overnight general election coverage.

    It was no huge surprise that Richard Dimbleby had proved so capable in the big Panorama chair. Having initially joined the BBC in 1936, he’d become the Corporation’s first war correspondent, going on to report from the battle of El Alamein, the D-Day landings and the liberation of the Bergen-Belsen concentration camp – Dimbleby threatening to resign over the latter due to the BBC initially declining to broadcast his despatch.

    Back on Civvy Street, Dimbleby was the BBC’s choice on commentating on events such as the 1953 Coronation, the first live television broadcast from the Soviet Union and the funeral of George VI. All that experience was put to good use behind the Panorama desk, conducting probing but well-mannered interviews with key figures of the day, plus putting his reporting skills to good use by helming live on-the-spot reports from the UK and overseas. Plus, in a skill that proved invariably useful given the propensity of mid-20th century technology to misbehave, he was more than adept at improvising during problems in running pre-recorded items or live links.

    That’s not to say Dimbleby didn’t also have a lighter side. This was most famously displayed on the first of April 1957, when he provided commentary to the infamous spaghetti-harvest hoax. So convincing was his delivery of the report, it’s said that even Director-General Ian Jacob was fooled by the pastariffic prank. All good things, however, must come to an end, and a tragically untimely end occurred in 1965, when Richard Dimbleby died at just 52. In his stead came a series of rotating anchors behind the Panorama desk, including Robin Day, Charles Wheeler and Leonard Parkin, but it would be Richard’s son David that would go on to have the longest association with the Panorama desk.

    Indeed, it was at that very desk where the most memorable unplanned moment in Panorama’s long history would occur. With the studio-based portion of the programme broadcast live, in the event of developing news, the anchor’s role at this stage was largely to introduce each filmed report. It also meant there’d be someone to throw back to if there were ever a technical problem with a filmed report, as could sometimes be the case in that pre-digital era of television, but there’s normally be little need to panic in such a situation. There’d be a backup filmed report on standby, ready to run. Just in case.

    Except for on 8 November 1976, when a there was a problem with film covering events in Rhodesia. Not to worry, thought the elder Dimbleboy (©Bernard Levin), onto the next filmed report looking at the IMF. Except, as a voice on the other end of the Dimblephone informed the presenter, the film on the IMF wasn’t available either. All there was to broadcast to millions of homes was live footage of Dave, the Panorama logo and an otherwise minimalist set. It wasn’t even as if he read out the script of the commentary from the report on Rhodesia, as it didn’t have any commentary, and the situation covered in the film on the IMF was deemed too “complicated” to simply explain. And so, the stricken presenter was left to announce that everyone would just need to sit in silence until something happened. Luckily for our intrepid host, that something was the issue with the Rhodesian report being resolved, and it could now be shown. Suboptimally however, it started playing out before he could introduce it.

    Stuff your Succession, THAT is watercooler television.

    Of course, for a large chunk of its run, Panorama wasn’t the only heavyweight current affairs strand on British television. Granada’s similarly weighty World in Action began in January 1963 and would run for 35 years. Initially, both aired at different times on Monday evenings, Panorama at 8:25pm, World in Action at 10:30pm, making a mouth-watering evening for anyone really into windows on the world. However, within a few years, both programmes were somehow sharing a slot at 8pm on Monday evenings (starting around July 1967, with World in Action having just returned as ‘World in Action’ after a couple of years under the unpopular – if less borrowed from the National Film Board of Canada – rebranding ‘The World Tonight’ and ‘The World Tomorrow’). Quite why this scheduling clash was suddenly the case is a bit of a mystery – a similar, if less Governmentally-sanctioned situation to God Slot programming going out on Sunday evenings? An admission that neither show would get large audiences unless there was more of the same on the other side? An attempt at encouraging some Whizzer and Chips rivalry? I’m not sure, but it certainly didn’t go unnoticed, and can’t have been popular with people who waited all week for some heavyweight reporting on current affairs before having to pick just one programme to watch.

    World in Action arrived on British screens having been, in the words of former producer Gus MacDonald, ‘born brash’. That was an ethos the production team kept to, with early series editor Tim Hewat having declared viewers wouldn’t stick to a half-hour of current affairs unless grabbed by the lapels and “sturdily intimidated into staying with it”. It was an approach that worked, a determined effort to marry film-makers with facts and journalists with moving pictures, and took British film journalism in a new direction. While Panorama had the likes of Dimbleby or Day asking the questions, World in Action would see interviewees converse with unidentified off-screen interrogators, throwing the subject into sharper focus. Series producers soon understood that putting incriminating photographs or documents exposing wrongdoers on screen seldom make for compelling viewing, so instead reporters would use tactics such as posing as Rhodesian sanctions busters or Biafran arms dealers to capture hidden camera footage that would prove more visually arresting. A tactic that Panorama, inexorably tied to Auntie Beeb’s apron, would find hard to emulate.

    Still, there was a tactic that Panorama could certainly employ to grab the attention of the audience: scare the living shit out of them. The programme had hardly been incident-free in the past – 1955 saw Christopher Mayhew take mescaline on camera and report on his experiences, though skittish management preventing the footage from airing at the time (it would later air as part of 1992 BBC2 theme night TV Hell, and lead to a fun series of sketches by Limmy). But with nuclear paranoia rising at a time when the threat of World War Three seemed an increasingly likely possibility (plus ca change, eh viewers?), 1980 saw arguably Panorama’s most controversial episode to date. If The Bomb Drops was an investigation fronted by Jeremy Paxman about what would actually happen if, well, the big one went up, along with the UK Government’s preparations for the public in such an event. A pretend spaghetti harvest it wasn’t.

    Here is a house. Oops, wrong programme.

    A similar furore had erupted in 1979, with a film on the Carrickmore incident attracting accusations that the Panorama editorial team were a little too friendly with the IRA. In 1982, a Panorama report on the RSPCA led to complaints (and ultimately, Broadcasting Complaints Commission censure) over the programme’s tactics in covering the society, but it was January 1984 that saw a real storm emerge. Panorama episode Maggie’s Militant Tendency claimed that three Tory MPs (Neil Hamilton, Harvey Proctor and Gerald Howarth) had links to far-right organisations in the UK and Europe. The story originated out of an internal Conservative Party report compiled by the chair of the Young Conservatives, and the programme makers had confirmed the status of the report with a Conservative vice chair, but the party was no less angry with the outcome. The MPs named in the report diligently avoided providing comments to the programme, and two of the MPs (Hamilton and Howarth) subsequently sued the Beeb and the Panorama production team. The trial was to start in October 1986, but within days of opening statements, the decision was made for the BBC to settle out of court. But not before Neil Hamilton’s “I’m very much not a racist” defence involved him doing a Basil Fawlty Hitler impression, so that’s something.

    Not even making that up. Daily Mirror, Friday 17 Oct 1986.

    And yet, despite hundreds of column inches being employed to cover Panorama, it still didn’t mean that viewers were flocking to it. And with World in Action still airing on ITV at the same time, it at least meant BBC-2 had a chance to attract a bumper audience. In the 1970s, this often meant American imports like The Waltons, The High Chaparral or Alias Smith and Jones found an appreciative audience before the slot was handed to popular homegrown offerings like Dave Allen at Large, The Mike Reid Show and Des O’Connor Tonight and the occasional curio I’d love to see, like The Amazing Randi Magic Show.

    Perhaps the best current affairs counterweight came in 1983, with the first episode of chat show/international comedy showcase The Bob Monkhouse Show. If you were going to give Lord Bob carte blanche to make any programme, this would undoubtedly have been the result, featuring interviews and live performances from comedy greats of the past, present and future, including the likes of Tommy Cooper, Bob Hope, Joan Rivers, Sid Caesar and Spike Milligan, plus early UK exposure for US-based acts like Steven Wright or The Unknown Comic.

    Back at Panorama, and 18 February 1985 saw the programme moved into a post-watershed slot for the first time since the mid-sixties, being shifted into a slot following the Nine O’Clock News. New BBC1 controller Michael Grade couldn’t have helped but notice that BBC2 was clobbering BBC1 in the ratings each Monday while Panorama was on, so the decision was made to afford the slot to something a little more popular with the viewing millions. Indeed, the first week of the Monday 8pm hour being freed up on BBC1 saw the opening episode from the tenth and final series of Are You Being Served? air to an audience of 14.5m viewers. Quite an increase on the 3.5m average figure Panorama had been enjoying in the same slot beforehand.

    The new post-news slot also led to a few format changes for the programme. Out went a desk in a dark studio, with the majority of episodes now dedicated to a single filmed report, with no in-vision host at all, and the runtime was reduced from fifty to forty minutes. People may not necessarily been watching in larger numbers – in early 1986, circumstance meant that it was still going out against The Bob Monkhouse Show on BBC2, though the presence of proper competition on ITV meant Bob’s audience had dropped from eight to around four million – but it was deemed worth the ratings hit to have something that weighty on air, and there would generally be a popular The Monday Film on straight afterwards to coax some viewers back over.

    Even if the conspiratorially-minded might think you’re heavily hinting at something sinister by having an episode on the NHS followed by Soylent Green.

    For several years, BBC2 would continue using the Panorama Is On The Other Side slot to put out popular shows – from Moonlighting in 1987 to The X-Files seven years later. But the hardy current affairs strand was certainly sturdy enough to be rolled out into a major slot when something big came along, such as a series of interviews with leaders of the main political parties in the run-up to the 1997 election, plus – famously or infamously – a certain Martin Bashir interview with a certain princess in 1995.

    Some classic BBC self-flagellation to come in later years when Panorama ran an episode exposing the tactics used by… Panorama to get the Diana interview.

    In October 2000, with the Nine O’Clock News being moved to 10pm (it’s okay, they renamed it to fit) and the 9pm hour being afforded to popular comedy series One Foot In The Grave and The Royle Family, there suddenly wasn’t much room in the schedule for Panorama on Monday nights, at least without shunting it into a slot skirting 11pm. And so, for the first time in the programme’s history, it was to start airing on Sunday nights. A slot at 10:15pm was hardly going to attract a lot of new viewers however, and despite the production team’s efforts to cover topics that would appeal to the viewing public (the first couple of Sunday night editions covered working conditions in Nike and Gap factories, and the US election campaign, nothing especially off-putting), it was a slot unlikely to attract many casual viewers.

    Thankfully, by 2007 BBC1 had a new Controller in Peter Fincham, and he made the decision to move Panorama back where it belonged – Monday evenings, and in a primetime 8:30pm slot to boot. Admittedly, that was the slot opposite ITV’s second Monday helping of Coronation Street, but that slot had worked well for the previous occupants Rogue Traders and DIY SOS, proving that as long as that slot contained a suitable alternative for soap naysayers, there’d be an audience happy to tune in. It certainly didn’t hurt that the new slot demanded the programme be trimmed to a leaner thirty-minute slot, and concentrate on topics likely to draw attention. Plus, of course, there were now dynamic sweeping shots of Jeremy Vine in the introduction for each episode.

    It was a tactic that was deemed to be a success, and indeed, Monday nights remains home to Panorama to this very day. The slot has been tweaked a little – it’s now going out at 7:30pm, still opposite Corrie, and occasionally airs on nights other than Monday, but it remains a programme that seems set to remain on our screens for a long time to come.


    Another one out of the way. Phew. Hopefully the next installment won’t require as much time-consuming research. Or, at the very least, have more things written about them than Working Lunch.

    SEE YOU NEXT TIME ARMCHAIR BRITAIN.

  • BABY BAB-AI! It’s the 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (22 and 21)

    BABY BAB-AI! It’s the 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (22 and 21)

    So close we can taste that top twenty.


    22: Eggheads

    (Shown 3049 times, 2003-2021)

    Hang on, what’s a Channel 5 programme doing on here?

    Admittedly, I really don’t know much about the series. Never watched it, and one time some work colleagues were thinking of taking part, and one suggested to me that they’d like me to become an Egghead with them. Given the person who’d asked me was bald, I was unable to immediately dispel the suspicion I was about to have my head shaved.

    Anyway, let’s crack out ChatGPT and see if I can work out where it’s wrong using my own feeble human brain? Over to you, Chatty. If nothing else, it’ll distract it from destroying society for a few minutes.

    “Eggheads” is a British television quiz show that first aired on BBC Two in 2003. The show is produced by 12 Yard Productions and is hosted by Jeremy Vine. The format of the show features a team of five contestants, known as the “challengers,” competing against a team of quiz experts known as the “Eggheads.”

    Oh dear. Not off to a great start. Eggheads actually started airing on BBC One in November 2003. Look, here’s the Genome entry and everything. Not a bigtime slot or anything, tucked away in lunchtime between a new episode of Cash In the Attic and the 1pm News bulletin. But still, BBC One. Not Two.

    It actually first aired on BBC Two in Monday 10 May 2004, going out at 2.55pm between an airing of 1955 Barbara Stanwyck vehicle Escape to Burma and a Flog It!, if you’re wondering.

    My feeble human brain: 1, AI: 0

    The original Eggheads team consisted of five members: Chris Hughes, Kevin Ashman, Judith Keppel, Daphne Fowler, and CJ de Mooi. Each member of the Eggheads team is a former quiz show champion, with several holding titles such as Mastermind and University Challenge champions.

    Yep, I’ll give you that.

    My feeble human brain: 1, AI: 1

    The show quickly became popular and was moved to a prime-time slot on BBC One in 2008. The format of the show has remained largely the same over the years, with each episode featuring a series of rounds of general knowledge questions.

    Well, it had mainly been a BBC One programme at first anyway. Of the first 70 broadcasts for Eggheads, 63 of them had been on BBC One. I’ll call for a steward’s enquiry over it quickly becoming popular, though. It took until 23 May 2005 for the ‘Heads to first arrive in the slot it’d be most closely associated with – weekdays at 6pm on BBC2, at which point it made a fleeting appearance in the weekly Barb Top Thirty for the channel – sneaking into the arse-end of the chart for the first couple of weeks in the teatime slot (between 24th and 29th place on the weekly lists for weeks ending 29 May 2005 and 5 June 2005, if you must know), but after that it disappeared from the Beeb ratings for BBC2 until August of that year, when a week of airings at 17:15 – a lead-in for a fresh batch of Weakest Links – saw it reach the BBC Two top ten for the first time. It wouldn’t return to that BBC2 top ten until the following May, and even then only for a single episode.

    My feeble human brain: 2, AI: 1

    Oh, and it never aired in a prime-time slot on BBC One, either. Don’t know where you picked that up from.

    My feeble human brain: 3, AI: 1

    The challengers are given the opportunity to select a category for each round, and the Eggheads team must answer questions on that topic. If the challengers answer more questions correctly, they win the round. If the Eggheads answer more questions correctly, they win the round.

    I mean, yes that’s technically correct. But you’re not getting a point for saying how a quiz works.

    My feeble human brain: 3, AI: 1 (Goal disallowed)

    Over the years, the Eggheads team has grown, with several members joining and leaving the team. Some notable former Eggheads include Barry Simmons, Pat Gibson, and Lisa Thiel. The current lineup of Eggheads includes Kevin Ashman, Judith Keppel, Barry Simmons, Chris Hughes, Steve Cooke, and Lisa Thiel.

    While the number of eggheads has indeed grown over the years, putting together a list of just three notable ‘former Eggheads’ that includes two people you then say are current Eggheads is poor form. For shame. Also: the current line-up of Eggheads doesn’t include Judith Keppel. She left in October 2022. Pfft.

    My feeble human brain: 4, AI: 1

    The show has been a success for the BBC, with over 2,000 episodes produced as of 2021. In addition to the main show, several spin-offs have been created, including “Celebrity Eggheads,” “Revenge of the Egghead,” and “Eggheads Jumbo Quiz.”

    Not going to knock the claim of ‘over 2,000 episodes’, as that’s the reason it’s here, so well done there. But, (and feel free to correct me in the comments, fellow squashy human brain beings) there’s never been a thing called “Eggheads Jumbo Quiz”. Poor show, ChatGPT.

    FINAL SCORE: My feeble human brain: 5, AI: 2

    CURRENT AI THREAT TO HUMANITY LEVEL:

    Yeah, right. Hey, Supposed AI Menace That Will Doom Us All, do a picture of you being outwitted by me, a genius.

    Bah.


    21: Pebble Mill

    (Shown 3137 times, 1972-2004)

    In this age of ENDLESS TELLY, it’s a bit weird to consider that back when Britain just had a tiny handful of channels to keep us entertained, they didn’t even bother broadcasting throughout the daylight hours, let alone overnight. If you’d scored a day off school with some horrible 70s Scarfolk disease (probably mumps), you might settle down on your brown and orange sofa, pull up your warming if scratchy blanket (also brown and/or orange) to watch whatever might be on telly. Except: the daytime TV menu seldom contained anything other than “For Schools comma Colleges”, which was hardly fun. Maybe there’ll be something else on after that… oh it’s an hour of the test card. Or, if you’re lucky, ‘Interval’.

    I always felt a bit cheated that I was born too late to see what the difference was between ‘Closedown’ and ‘Interval’. Presumably one of them had different music to the other. Anyway, it was all the fault of that ruddy Postmaster General, limiting the aggregate totals of hours in which TV can broadcast in a given week, meaning Britain’s TV companies sensibly opted to do so during hours where more people would be watching. If you were a daytime viewer, the occasional public service remit broadcast of Nai Zindagi Naya Jeevan (see list passim) or Dechrau Canu Dechrau Canmol (see a small part of a future list-part) might be all you get.

    However, October 1972 brought a bit of good news for Sickday Britons – the GPO bigwigs loosened their grip on the broadcasting reins, affording the nation Proper Daytime Telly for the first time. Nothing new before noon during termtime, mind – those hours were still reserved for broadcasting programmes for schools and colleges, but at least the hours between the lunchtime news and the start of children’s programming around 3pm could be filled with something other than Test Card F. And so, from Monday 2 October 1972, BBC-1 viewers got to experience Pebble Mill At One for the first time.

    Welcomed to the airwaves by the Daily Telegraph’s Richard Last as “one of the first genuinely new programmes to emerge from unrestricted daytime hours”, Pebble Mill At One offered up at least a couple of new things.

    THING ONE: a daily jaunt to plucky upstart regional outpost, um, Birmingham. Hey, it was a novelty at the time.

    THING TWO: The whole affair coming from the foyer of the titular (and for the period, pretty darned modern) Pebble Mill studios. For a nation used to the hard-hitting likes of Tonight, 24 Hours and Panorama, this was a much gentler affair under the auspices of editor Terry Dobson. No custard creams were in danger of being dropped into cuppas.

    If nothing else, it was probably a relief to the BBC that the building was doing something to help earn its upkeep. Constructed at the cost of £6m and initially decried as a white elephant, by the time Pebble Mill at One came along, the studios themselves – all 6500 square feet of them – were often filled to capacity (which might explain the need to fill At One in the foyer), but it took a while to reach that stage, such was the concentration of TV talent in London during those early years.

    …At One came about thanks to former manager of BBC Radio Leeds, Phil Sidey. By 1972, he’d found himself in the role of Head of Network Production Centre, Birmingham, and having previously worked on 24 Hours and Nationwide, he certainly knew his way around a daily live production. Using his contemporary Midlands location, he was able to offer viewers what was considered a “non-Metropolitan view” of British life, which certainly helped sell the concept to BBC1 controller Paul Fox. With their moneyed rivals over at ITV busily preparing their own daytime TV schedule, a thrifty Beeb was never going to have the budget to take on an ITV line-up containing the likes of Emmerdale Farm, Lunchtime with Wogan or Crown Court on their own terms. But it did have that innate BBC talent at putting together reliable live programming on a daily basis.

    To front the programme, former newsreader Bob Langley was chosen, having been deemed suitably avuncular for the new programme. Throw in a theme tune and title sequence that made the whole thing look like a precursor to Dynasty, and Cup-a-Soup Britain would never be the same again.

    As mentioned, it was certainly didn’t hurt that BBC Pebble Mill was finally being used frequently. Theoretically, given its status as a single entity, the BBC should have been freed from the multifranchise bunfight between the big ITV regions trying to get their own shows to a national audience. In reality, the BBC regions were having an equally tough time getting their content shown nationally, with niche shows turned breakout hits like Pot Black or Gardener’s World the kinds of exceptions that found regular audiences.

    The hope was that this would change. Pebble Mill became home to an English Regions Drama department, headed by David Rose, original producer of Z Cars, with fare from the department including a series of Thirty-Minute Theatre plays, alongside provincial offerings for the Play For Today strand. Luckily, things soon worked out for the Pebble Mill Studios, with it going on to become home to (at least briefly) Top Gear, Doctors, Telly Addicts, Howards’ Way, Juliet Bravo amongst others.

    Back to 1972 and the studio’s daytime mainstay, and the Times didn’t seem particularly enamoured with the new programme, with TV reviewer Stanley Reynolds referring to it as “aggressively lower brow” and (it’s still 1972 there, this wasn’t as much of a cliche then) something that “makes Blue Peter look like Panorama”. He’d waited until December to write that, too.

    Despite that stinging broadsheet rebuke, Pebble Mill at One went on to because a resolute rock within BBC-1’s daytime schedule, gradually picking up a fiercely loyal audience. Plus, it didn’t exactly hurt that it saw plenty of Golden Age of Light Entertainment stars popping in for a lunchtime chat.

    And, this being something I have to mention as it always pleases me, if circumstances led to it going out at a time other than 1pm sharp, the programme title was occasionally amended accordingly:

    By 1974, the programme was popular enough to warrant its very own Christmas specials. Still in the daytime schedule (on 23 and 24 December, mind), but they’re using the word ‘spectacular’ in the listing, so something big must have been going on. Not big enough to let them borrow an actual studio, but still.

    In 1976, Pebble Mill at One was considered such a safe pair of weekday hands, the decision was made to make a Saturday night spin-off of the programme. As such, Saturday Night at the Mill roared into life at 11.30pm on 6 March 1976, pretty much as post-watershed as it was possible to get. So, what debauchery could an audience who’ve just tumbled in from the Dog and Trumpet with a belly full of Watneys expect? Well, the Daily Mirror’s preview of the programme promised a programme every bit as “bland, folksy and fairly predictable” as the daytime counterpart. Indeed, the safe pairs of hands Bob Langley and Donn MacLeod were on hosting duties, with the premiere episode featuring guests Michael Bentine, Elaine Delmar and Buddy Greco. There was also time for “a nostalgic look at British films and television of twenty years ago”.

    Not going to lie, that’s probably preferable to The Jonathan Ross Show on ITV.

    While it hardly set the TV schedules ablaze at the time, Saturday Night at the Mill certainly proved a sturdy weekend outpost for BBC1, running until July 1981. The final episode saw hosts Bob Langley and Jenny Hanley joined by Honor Blackman, Griff Rhys Jones and Edward Woodward. Not a bad way to bow out. And at least they’d finally settled on a co-host for Langley by that point. Previous co-hosts had included Hayley Mills, Liza Goddard and writer Anrianna Stassinopoulos, none of whom apparently proved a success. The latter reportedly failed as a result of her Greek accent proving impenetrable to the parochial ears of the viewing public – Stassinopoulos lasted just five episodes.

    Additionally, if nothing else, Saturday Night… led to one of the great Not Quite The Right Names Of The Programme listings in 1977:

    28 Dec 1977

    Back at the day job, O.G. Pebble Mill at One would continue all the way through to 1986 (despite having their special ‘Pebble Mill at Ten‘ celebration in 1982 kicking off with the Black and sodding White sodding Minstrels), but by then it was time for BBC1’s shiny new daytime schedule to take over. Out went the old guard (mainly Programmes For Schools and Colleges, which shuffled over to BBC2), and in came the new Daytime UK line-up. At the hand of then-BBC1 Controller Michael Grade, Pebble Mill at One made way for a new One O’Clock News bulletin, and in October 1987 the Pebble Mill at One chat-and-chicken-soup remit was to be fulfilled by brand new early afternoon chat show ‘Daytime Live’. Which came live each lunchtime from… Pebble Mill studios in Birmingham.

    By 1990, the fairly bland title of Daytime Live was abandoned for the equally unmemorable ‘Scene Today’, which really sounds more like a regional news bulletin. And so, with no small sense of inevitability, 1991 saw Pebble Mill returned to Britain’s screens, this time shorn of the ‘at One’ suffix. The regular set within the lobby of Pebble Mill Studios was retained, but by now the likes of Bob Langley had been replaced with Alan Titchmarsh, but the regular recipe of light chat and light music was retained.

    Then, in 1996, this happened.

    Clearly, things had got badly out of control. In March of that year, the final regular edition of Pebble Mill aired on BBC1.

    And that was it. Save for a single retrospective programme on Pebble Mill, made to mark the closure of the storied studios in 2004.


    Phew, we got there. Sorry this was a bit of low-energy effort this time. A proper piece of Heavyweight BBC Programming in the next update, however. See you next time, armchair Britain.

  • The 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (24 and 23)

    The 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (24 and 23)

    I’m back from holiday. With exhaustion and a cold, which feels unfair. Anyway, back to the chart rundown that’s dragging on so long you’ve lost interest.


    24: Teletubbies

    (Shown 2977 times, 1997-2009)

    Eh? Oh.

    It’s funny how, once a product of a genre becomes truly massive, most people completely forget what had previously seemed to be the go-to example from that genre. For example, before Street Fighter II came along, what was the go-to-reference for a one-on-one fighting game? Yie Ar Kung-Fu? Punch-Out? Frank Bruno’s Boxing? Good as they seemed at the time, nobody’s clamouring to pump out 2023 sequels to those, are they? Meanwhile, Channel Five aren’t about to throw together (and almost immediately shelve) a documentary series on The New Wave of New Wave, are they?

    “He’s about to fight Mike Tyson, quick, throw out a re-release!”

    And, similarly, in the mid-1990s it seemed like TV for pre-schoolers wasn’t about to get any bigger than Tots TV. Produced by Ragdoll Productions and Central, this started in 1993 and the title certainly made no bones about who the target audience was. Despite the generic title that, at least to me, sounds more like a programme strand than something with an actual premise, it had… an actual premise. Basically, following the lives of three puppet housemates: Tilly, a flame-haired French girl (with her nationality changed accordingly when shown in other countries), blue-haired smartarse Tom, and green-haired youngling Tiny.

    Tots TV became a major hit, at the time becoming the nation’s most popular pre-school TV programming and shifting VHS compilations by the truckload. Admittedly, at this point, the bar for pre-school telly didn’t seem particularly high. A Sunday Telegraph article on Tots TV form June 1996 mentions that the most popular pre-school video in the USA at the time was called Baby Mugs, and basically featured close-ups of babies’ faces set to music. And, to help market the videos, parents with especially attractive babies were given free copies of the tapes in return for allowing their own children to be taped for a future volume. So, several degrees more disquieting than Kiddystare from The Day Today.

    All of which might explain the easy pickings for Ragdoll Productions when it sold Tots TV to the US television market. That wasn’t enough for Ragdoll, however. Around the time Tots TV dominated the under-fives market, Ragdoll carried out research at nurseries and family homes around the UK, filming the reactions of toddlers to their Tots TV follow-up. The company’s producer of programmes Anne Wood stated at the time “we want to make a programme for the under-fives that will make them laugh and increase their thinking skills”. To help secure the attention of the toddler audience, Watch With Mother-style ‘proper’ pronunciation was trimmed back, replaced with the indistinct speech patterns the audience would be familiar with. If you were under three, these weren’t more adults telling you what to do, these were friends you wanted to spend time with.

    That research led to a different approach for the new programme. Gone was the manic energy of shows like Pob or Chorlton and the Wheelies, and in came a gentler pace, specifically to give the audience a little more time to stop, listen and consider the action. And, quite crucially, key elements of the programme would be repeated. Nails on a blackboard for parents, but a key tool in understanding for the show’s real audience. Plus, test audiences actually loved the scary baby-face sun, confirming that toddlers really are Very Strange.

    DRUM ROLL: and that programme was… you know what it was. A show described in a later Telegraph article as “four technological babies are linked to reality via televisions in their stomachs”. And so, on 31 March 1997, Tinky Winky, Laa Laa, Dipsy and Po arrived on the BBC for the first time. And to show just how much faith the Beeb had placed in the series, it seized the slot then held by pre-school stalwart Playdays. No pressure.

    It was something truly at odds with the trend at the time. While Teletubbies was being developed, Sony were churning out videos such as ‘Dirty Diapers Dancing’, ‘Gurgles and Giggles’ and ‘Multiple Madness’, where infants performed an approximation of dancing to cheap-to-licence pop songs. Sure, the adorability quotient will have been high for a certain type of parent (y’know, fellow parents you regret accepting Facebook friend requests from), but that’s really offering little more than a distraction for the audience.

    Anne Wood’s different but carefully considered approach soon won over audiences when the programme first appeared in the BBC schedules, but that did little to sway journos looking for an easy way to fill column inches. Hey, it’s popular with a generation different from yours – your instinct will be to immediately distrust it, yeah?

    Daily Mail, 20 May 1997
    Daily Mirror, 23 May 1997

    The big phone vote debate in the following weekday’s Daily Mirror was on abortion, just to you know the level we’re on here.

    Tabloid outrage factories put in extra overtime in July 1997 when Tinky Winky actor Dave Thompson was withdrawn from the series, producers citing his ‘interpretation of the role [being] not acceptable’. A frenzied dig into Thompson’s past uncovered (at least according to the Daily Mail, so have a pinch of salt ready) his habit of relaxing in the nude while out of costume on filming days.

    Daily Mail, 31 July 1997
    Daily Mirror, 28 July 1997

    Even the broadsheets were easily coaxed into the pile-on, with The Times coupling a story on less than healthy licenced ‘Tubbies-branded snacks with a footnote on research from Paris on increased risk of heart attacks for overweight children.

    The Times, 26 October 2001

    Even the Telegraph, the newspaper that had highlighted the research and reasoning that went into the series months before it launched were happy to jump in.

    Daily Telegraph, 20 May 1997

    Also in the UK, and even in the USA, right-wing hacks found plenty to cram into their outrage pipes about the notion that Tinky Winky was promoting a gay lifestyle because handbag. Once everyone with an ounce of sense had finished rolling their eyes at the manufactured furore, LGBT activist David Smith offered an assurance to the parents of the world that “your children will not become gay due to the subversive effects of the colour purple, triangles and magic bags.”

    And yet, it was Tinky Winky et al who’d have the last laugh. The Fleet Street furore died down, and Teletubbies became one of Britain’s great television exports, going on to air in 120 countries and in 45 different languages. It seeped so far into the public’s consciousness on both sides of the Atlantic, it was go-to reference-fodder for everything from Have I Got News For You to Harry Enfield and Chums over here, and for The Simpsons to Family Guy over there. It was even jostling with the likes of Irvine Welsh, Kathy Lette and J G Ballard in the bestsellers list at one point.

    Independent, 27 Sept 1997

    The original run of the series only saw new episodes produced between 1997 and 2001, but that didn’t prevent them being aired on a daily basis for years afterwards. And that was far from the end of the saga – in 2015, the series was rebooted for a new generation of tots to enjoy on CBeebies, with episodes still in production in 2022. And they certainly weren’t doing things by halves – the opening theme music is performed by the BBC Philharmonic Orchestra.

    On a personal level, this is the first programme on the entire rundown where I’ve personally met the cast.

    Yeah, you’re right to look impressed.


    23: Kilroy

    (Shown 3005 times, 1986-2004)

    “Your mother’s in a care home? And is being drugged? For the convenience of the staff?”

    “No!”

    “Your daughter, she’s about to get married. And you just threw black ink all over her dress?”

    “I never touched her!”

    October 1986 was a real transitional moment in the great timeline of British television. With Programmes For Schools and Colleges now airing over on BBC2, BBC1 stuck an arm down the back of the Breakfast Time sofa and rustled up enough cash to afford a brand new daytime schedule. All they needed was fresh content to fill it with. A lot of fresh content. Eventually, for one of the slots, they’d land on the programme under consideration here. But it took a while to get there.

    Daily Mirror, 15 Oct 1986

    Nominally, the new daytime schedule started at 10am, the post-Breakfast Time slot had long been enjoying actual programming for the benefit of anyone needing a post-Bough comedown before the white heat of Pages From Ceefax. Indeed, it took a little while for that slot to fully become part of the new Daytime BBC1 line-up, leaving it free to host all manner of filler between 27 October and 24 November 1986. On Day One of the new daytime schedule, the slot was taken by Who’s a Pretty Girl, Then?, a documentary following a beauty pageant for girls aged three-to-nine, and all manner of flotsam soon floated there: Pigeons – Queer Facts, On the Throne, a few early broadcasts of Neighbours, Emergency – Bloomsbury 3 and The Last Day.

    Eventually, on 24 November 1986, British television welcomed a long-planned vehicle for a man who, upon being elected as Labour MP for Knowsley North in 1974, confidently predicted he’d be Prime Minister within 15 years. That plan having been scuppered by Militant, Robert Kilroy-Silk made the move to television, but not without lobbing a few bricks over his shoulder as he left – timing his headline-nabbing official resignation from Parliament on the day of Neil Kinnock’s keynote speech at the Labour Party Conference, and releasing his tell-all diary telling of his disillusion with the party being published on the first day of the conference – it also being serialised in Rupert Murdoch’s Times.

    Daily Mirror, 1 Aug 1986
    Daily Mirror, 6 Aug 1986. Yes, it is that Anne Robinson.

    And so, a television career beckoned for the former lecturer, and as everyone knows, that programme was called… Day to Day.

    Not that one.

    Yep, Kilroy-Silk’s original discussion-based programme went by that title, running for 107 episodes between November 1986 and May 1987, mostly with a billing that offered viewers a chance to “join Robert Kilroy-Silk to discuss a topic that touches your life.” Given it’s position on the nascent BBC1 Daytime schedule, you might expect the programme veer away from anything too rabble-rousy. After all, it shared a schedule with Five To Eleven. Looking at some newspaper television listings at random from 1987 may provide some answers.

    5 Jan 1987: “Robert Kilroy-Silk, Patric Walker. Jilly Cooper and a studio audience discuss astrology.”

    3 February 1987: “Robert Kilroy-Silk is joined by two convicted burglars who confront a studio audience of victims of burglary to explain why burglars rob people.”

    19 March 1987: “Robert Kilroy-Silk chairs debate on compulsory sterilisation of the mentally handicapped. With Brian Rix of MENCAP.”

    Bloody hell, that escalated quickly.

    At the end of the run, half-term children’s programming filed the 9.05am slot, followed by Election Call and repeats of Dallas in subsequent weeks. Bye, Day to Day. But in October 1987, Kilroy-Silk was back. And he meant business.

    By that time, ITV had found their own rugged morning discussion show host, with Mike Scott’s The Time… The Place – the first daytime show to be aired throughout the national ITV network – attracting a solid million viewers per day. Time for the BBC to fight back, with their very own “golden-haired hero out of a Barbara Cartland novel” (as the Daily Mirror’s Patricia Smyllie put it) front and centre.

    “I never run out of ideas, and I like the challenge of facing a similar programme on the other channel”, roared the silky-smooth one. “You get the sort of publicity you get nowhere else. I once turned down an early morning breakfast show because I refused to get up at 5am. They were amazed because no one had ever refused before. No one has refused to go on my show either.”

    Not that there was much different between Day to Day and the renamed Kilroy!, to be honest, at least during those early programmes. But putting the name of the host in the titles was surely a canny move for a man fast becoming a cult figure amongst daytime viewers. Prior to his debut on daytime TV, the Daily Mirror had little positive to say about the former MP. Within a few months of Day to Day hitting the screens, the same publication would frequently publish puff pieces cooing over Kilroy-Silk:

    All over Britain. Hoovers are switched off, dusters put down, Nescafe brewed. legs curled up on sofas. as a sizeable proportion of the female population settle down for a good old-fashioned fawn.

    One was moved enough to write a poem to the BBC viewers’ letters show Points Of View which read:
    “If you want your day to be honey and milk
    “Start each one with Kilroy-Silk.”

    “As Smooth as Silk”, Colin Wills, Sunday Mirror, 1 March 1987

    And that was at a time when Kilroy-Silk was penning opinion pieces for rival rag The Times. So, the same mix of discussion on topical subjects was rechristened with a third of the host’s moniker. The topics certainly remained a consistently inconsistent mix of the controversial and cliched: “Clause 28” (26 January 1988), “Maybe working women make better mums?” (3 March 1988), “Astrology” (again) 13 May 1988.

    It was a formula that proved to be a hit with many viewers, and led to a number of special episodes for the permatanned host. 1989 saw a one-off special (and not, as you’d more reasonably expect, a Davey Jones strip for Viz) Kilroy in the Holy Land, where he and his guests “discussed prospects for peace”. That was followed by 1990’s Kilroy in Hong Kong, where Kilroy-Silk listened to the anxieties and hopes of the people of the colony as it inched towards 1997’s transfer of power. 1992 saw Kilroy on the Costa, while 1994 saw Kilroy Down Under.

    Those overseas sojourns were accompanied by runs of Kids on Kilroy (1992) and Kids’ Kilroy (1994-1995), where topics were (thankfully) watered down to the likes of “Do brothers and sisters always have to love each other, or is an only child better off?”, “How do Britain’s next generation look at people in authority?” or “Young people talk about the clothes they like wearing and why“. I mean, because they’d get cold otherwise, probably.

    As the new millennium whizzed by, Kilroy remained (for the most part) a fixture on the BBC. Surely nothing was about to derail his conversational juggernaut?

    Oh, right. Yeah. That’ll probably do it. Still, plenty more channels out there who’ll welcome his no-nonsense approach. Onward and upward.

    I'm aware that Shafted aired a few years before Kilroy! was yanked off air. But really, I couldn't not have included that picture. [If you're too young to understand this reference: search YouTube for "Kilroy Silk Shafted", of preferably don't]

    Oh, right. Yeah.


    Phew. Another one down. Will we ever reach number one on the list? Tune in again soon to get a few inches closer to that numerical utopia.

  • The 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (26 and 25)

    The 100 Most-Broadcast BBC Programmes Of All Time (26 and 25)

    The next episode of the rundown. And a concerted effort not to bang on about everything for so long. We’ll see. And so, resisting the temptation to pretend Does China Exist? is at number 25 as an April Fool prank, here are the next couple of programmes.


    26: The Weakest Link

    (Shown 2923 times, 2000-2021)

    Now, here’s a programme that seemed to mark a sea change on how popular quiz shows could break out of the confines of telly, and become an entire self-contained industry.

    Not that TV quizzes hadn’t led to spin-off merch before, of course.

    But The Weakest Link took things to a level never seen before. Alongside compilation tapes, the inevitable board games and question books, there were (equally inevitable) CD-ROMs, games for the PlayStation AND PlayStation 2, a VHS compilation of Anne Robinson put-downs, novelty dance records, collectable action figures of the host’s appearance in an episode of Doctor Who, and a money box.

    Truly, the early 2000s were the peak years of TV tie-in tat.

    All stemming from a quiz programme that quietly arrived on BBC Two’s early evening schedule on Monday 14 August 2000.

    The premise was summed up suitably succinctly by the Radio Times for that week: “Anne Robinson hosts a new series of weekday elimination quiz shows. Contestants face quick-fire, general-knowledge questions to win a top prize of £10,000.” Devised by former South London GP Fintan Coyle and club comedian/actor Cathy Dunning, the format was certainly one that could attract an audience – making contestants work together in each all-contestant round-robin, as they seek to inflate a cash accumulator that rises with each correct answer, but resets to zero after an incorrect answer with the current accumulator total being lost. If a contestant ‘banks’ the current prize pot before their question is asked, it’s reset to zero, but added to the final prize pot – however, you’re also stopping that accumulator climbing any higher. That teamwork is offset by a voting round after each set of questions, a ballot that results in the contestants voting out one of their number. In theory, they’re voting out the titular weak link who’d cost them the most money, but as the field narrows, canny contestants can choose to vote out anyone they deem the biggest threat to their personal success. For anyone too young to remember it, it’s basically Among Us but with trivia. Except that when you’re kicked off the spaceship in Among Us, you’re not expected to go on camera to account for your actions in a post-match interview.

    Eventually, the field is whittled down to two contestants, who must then take part in a penalty shoot-out: five questions each, whoever gets the most right out of five scoops the prize pot, and if it’s a draw it’s a sudden death question-by-question shootout. I don’t think that Israel Football Association general secretary Joseph Dagan got a credit at the end of the programme for devising that bit, but he originally invented the penalty shoot-out, so he should probably at least get a cut of those DVD sales. [UPDATE 11/04/23: See footnote 1 below.]

    Of course, while the format of the programme was undoubtedly a unique one, the secret spicy sauce behind the success of the programme came from the acerbic nature of host Anne Robinson.

    While the original intent was for Robinson to be firm but generally understanding with the contenders under her charge, before too long underperforming players could expect to be gently mocked by Robinson. Before much longer, the mocking retorts became much less gentle, ranging from cutting to downright insulting. I’ll admit here, this is why I never personally took to the programme. Seriously, comments like “Why are you dressed like a lesbian?” and “How many of your three boys have got tags on their ankles?” to people appearing on telly for the first time in their lives? What are you, Jeremy Kyle in a frock? No wonder it led directly to the election of Donald Trump and Boris Johnson. Yes, directly.

    (Not directly, I’m exaggerating for comic effort. Smelly.)

    Anyway, putting that brief moral aside behind us, it was a programme that was an absolute smash for the BBC. Just a few months after the programme first hit BBC2, show creators Coyle and Dunning were well on the way to becoming millionaires, and the show was soon set to be franchised out to Germany, Italy, Australia, France, the Netherlands, Portugal, South Africa, Israel, Turkey, Spain, Latin America, Sweden, Canada and Ireland, each installing their own Queen (or King) of Mean as host.

    And, biggest of all, from April 2001, a primetime version of the series started airing on America’s very own NBC, with Anne Robinson travelling across the Atlantic to host. The “getting a Briton to play the villain” trope is written in ink, after all. Since the early days of television, well-regarded British TV personalities have made the trip to US only to return to the UK hoping nobody noticed they’d been missing – on one end of the scale, Peter Cook in The Two of Us and Morwenna Banks’ short stint at SNL, and the other Cheryl Cole’s cameo in X Factor USA and ABC’s The Noel Edmonds Show.

    This actually happened. For a week in 1986.

    At least initially, NBC’s version of The Weakest Link was a success. After launching in April 2001, the series was an immediate hit, the three episodes airing that debut week (on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday) barged into the Nielsen ratings for the week, attracting audiences as high as 17.4 million viewers, and bettering the likes of Frasier, 60 Minutes and even Friends. Not too shabby.

    Source: RatingsRyan

    However, it wasn’t to last. By 2002, American audiences found a new Briton they could love to hate in American Idol’s Simon Cowell, and by July of that year the Weakest Link was dropped from NBC’s primetime line-up.

    That wasn’t the end of the series in the USA, however. Several months before the cancellation of the primetime version, NBC had started work on a syndicated daytime version of the series for local stations, which had started airing in January of that year. This time the host was George Gray, at the time best-known for hosting “an extreme version of The Gong Show”, and the newly-syndicated version ran for 324 episodes. (“Wow! It must have been a success!” – A reader.) Not really, it only lasted for a season and a half. Such is syndication.

    Robinson duly returned to the UK, and resumed hosting duties for the OG Weakest Link. Not that they’d been left without their premier quiz show in the interim – BBC Two started airing episodes of Weakest Link USA on weekday evenings from May 2001, just a few weeks after their debut on NBC. There were enough episodes of that to last until April 2003, so not a bad bit of business for the Beeb. Not least at by 2002, as new Celebrity editions of The Weakest Link were going out on primetime BBC1, which really helped the brand to grow even further. And boy, it certainly did grow. The 1 March 2001 episode of The Weakest Link on BBC1 – an EastEnders special, broadcast as the warm-up act for an extended ‘Stenders episode featuring Mel and Steve’s wedding – drew a series-high audience of 11.4m viewers.

    (With thanks to Daniel Webb for those details on the EE-special episode.)

    Given how well-known the programme was in the early 00s, it’s a bit surprising to consider how the proletariat version of TV’s most caustic quiz didn’t make the move to teatime BBC1 until February 2008. But, to be fair, until that point the 5:15pm slot on the Beeb’s flagship channel was the sole domain of a certain antipodean continuing drama programme, the name of which escapes me right now. Whatever happened to that?

    I think it was this one. Sub: please check.

    Given the reputation Weakest Link held, it was perhaps no surprise that it could easily be jettisoned into that spot in the schedules – by that point it had topped the weekly BARB ratings for BBC2 on at least 82 occasions – and it cemented that timeslot as the BBC1’s go-to location for popular teatime gameshows to this very day.

    Of course, all good things etc etc and so on. On 31 March 2012, a new episode of the programme aired for the last time, though repeats of the show would continue on BBC Two throughout 2013. However! In December 2021 – right at the end of the period we’re looking at for the purposes of this rundown, remember (seems a bloody age ago, doesn’t it?) – the Weakest Link returned, hosted by the omnipresent Romesh Ranganathan. It doesn’t look like going anywhere any time soon, even if it’ll never hope to recapture that place in the national psyche.

    [footnote one: QI KLAXON.

    10 bonus points to Suze on the qi.com forum for the following addendum.]


    25: Nationwide

    (Shown 2930 times, 1969-1983)

    This was always going to make the list, it was just a matter of where.

    It feels redundant saying a television programme encapsulated the era when it was aired. After all, which era is it supposed to encapsulate? The middle ages? The year three billion? And yet, it’s a facile phrase that seems to fit especially well with Nationwide, from the “don’t expect to get too much” years of 1969-1983. Yes, there’s a skateboarding duck, but here’s the local news telling you the local coalmine is closing. Ha, a man who claims to jump on eggs, anyway the binman strike is about to enter week twelve. And so on. Give with one hand, knock your Bovril onto the carpet with the other.

    Following in the footsteps of acclaimed current affairs show Tonight, and tasked with folding your local news into itself somewhere, Nationwide found itself needing to offer something new. And to do this, it offered something that those upstarts on ITV couldn’t match.

    Over on ITV, each regional service was operated by an entirely individual company, so while each region was able to offer a local news service, there’d be no way they could put out a single nightly show that could flit around the regions, seeing what various parts of the UK had to offer. At least not until the ITV Telethon became a thing almost twenty years later.

    The BBC, being one single entity offering a largely national service (at least to England) with regional opt-outs, could put everything into one nightly programme. Start off with a national presenter topping the programme and giving a round-up of Things to Come, have each region opt-out of the programme for their own local news bulletin (save for London and the South-East, which had a bulletin broadcast from the main Nationwide studio), then back to the London studio for a mixture of political analysis, consumer affairs, light entertainment and sports. Best of all, where stories of national interest (or at least curiosity value) were located outside London, the national network had the relevant regional studio ready to be thrown to. A unique mixture that their rivals couldn’t hope to match. An easy win.

    Going by the words of contemporary critics, any such aims were perhaps a little too lofty, at least at the time of the first edition. Writing in the Daily Mirror, TV reviewer Mary Malone set the BBC’s new evening offering against its Thames counterpart ‘Today’ in an entertaining column that required two television sets to be on at the same time (video recorders? Pah!). Today became the main focus of the column, if only as a suitable target for ire over their sensationalist coverage of contraceptives in use at a secondary school, and using rock music to soundtrack war footage. Malone’s eye was clearly drawn more closely to the unfolding schlock on the light channel, leaving time for just the faintest of praise for Nationwide. “Responsible, incombustible stuff this; no town councillor can afford to miss it.”

    Oof. Peter Black of the Daily Mail was able to go into a bit more detail about the lack of pizazz hampering the debut episode of Nationwide: the lack of any topical content that would befit the format. Noting that “technically, it was a good clean professional job. In content it was dullish because as always happens on a first night, there weren’t enough good stories about.”

    Indeed, the story falling under the first Nationwide spotlight was one that was happening, well, nationwide. The national teacher shortage may well have been big news that night, but throwing to Glasgow, Newcastle and Birmingham from the London studio only to be met with “yeah, same here” hardly highlighted Britain’s rich regional tapestry. Fortunately, any early jitters don’t seem to have held the programme back, and in 1972 the programme’s scheduling was increased to five days per week.

    Before too long, the programme would become a lynchpin of the BBC1 evening schedule, and become a target recognisable enough to be the target of sketches by, among others, Monty Python’s Flying Circus (“Well, everyone is talking about the Third World War which broke out this morning. But here on `Nationwide’ we’re going to get away from that a bit and look instead at the latest theory that sitting down regularly in a comfortable chair can rest your legs”) and the marvellous End Of Part One.

    Despite making for quite an easy target, the Nationwide branding was deemed to have enough dignity to be sellotaped to the BBC’s coverage of various then-current events. So, alongside the vanilla version of the programme at teatime, viewers could also expect to see the “Nationwide BBC Election 70 Results Round-up”, the “Nationwide Referendum Result”, assorted “Nationwide Budget Specials”, compilation show “Launch Yourself with Nationwide” where Richard Stilgoe demonstrated building a dinghy.

    Perhaps best of all, between 1979 and 1983 there was “The British Rock and Pop Awards: A Nationwide Special”. Imagine the Brits being given a “One Show Special” tagline today, eh? This actually span out of the Daily Mirror’s annual Rock and Pop Awards, which had been running since 1976. But from 1979 onwards, the paper teamed up with the ‘Wide and Radio 1 to let people see and hear the whole shebang.

    The march of modernisation must never abate, however. Come 1983, and the programme was deemed a bit old hat, and on 5 August 1983, the nation went Nationwide for the very last time. In its place came a super new replacement programme that BBC bigwigs were sure everyone would love.

    Spoiler alert: they didn’t. Despite a more urgent theme tune, flashy (for the time) graphics and a weird Rubik’s Snake logo, Sixty Minutes turned out to have been a bit of a binfire, the bright idea of combining the national news, local news and current affairs into a single entity fell apart when the BBC’s News department failed to play nicely with their Current Affairs counterparts, meaning each part of the programme was effectively a single entity. It lasted less than a year, and the BBC made the switch to individual national and regional news bulletins – a format still in use to this very day.

    The BBC still haven’t found anything quite as magnificent as the spinny Nationwide wheel, though.

    POSTSCRIPT: Mary Malone’s TV column looking at Today and Nationwide, as mentioned above, is worth reading in full. So, here it is:

    I SUPPOSE you could call it an Indian summer. After the first flush of new autumn programmes, a pause while they get a grip on their generosity, No one was flinging any money away last night.

    It was back to an old film, a repeat play and the die-hard favourites.
    No doubt you were all worried about me. What could I make of a might like this?

    Let me tell you now, children, I’ve made bricks without straw before, and I’ll make ’em again. It’s facility that has provoked a number of shrewd inquiries. Those who don’t ask why you do it usually ask how. Do you watch three sets at once? How do you remember it all? Why choose “World in Action” and not “Panorama,” a comedy and not Misery in the slums by Man Alive.

    Wonders

    Well. here’s how: the first thing to master is mounting anxiety at the sight of the evening’s schedules. When in doubt, polish everything. Waxing the floor does wonders. Anxiety recedes in direct proportion to energy expended and has the added bonus of forcing spiders back to the garden.

    Then make a cup of tea, switch on both sets, turn the radio up, and spread the day’s papers on the floor; anything may be useful.

    It’s all in aid of that precious and essential moment when something goes “ping”; and an idea docks.

    Watching two sets at once is for emergencies only. It is unduly stimulating and can give you the jitters.

    But when the only hope is a bolt of lightning, I’ll try anything. I refer, of course, to the news magazines “Today,” ITV and “Nationwide” (BBC-1) — on both sets simultaneously.

    “Nationwide” does go on. Its choice of topics is dictated by what is common — to bring in the regions.

    Pill

    Mention a fire, and you are good for two minutes. Or land preservation. Or housing. Responsible, incombustible stuff this; no town councillor can afford to miss it.

    Meanwhile on the other set “Today” was busy coaxing little girls to say whether or not they felt their education on contraceptives was adequate.

    The children were registering grave alarm over the lack, in the school curriculum, of clear and forthright instructions on the use of the Pill, the coil and the diaphragm. “It should start at eleven,” said one sweet thing, very firmly. The little darlings!

    Clonk

    What has happened to the world since I grew up? This was not so much of a ping but more of a clonk. But the insatiable “Today” was not finished.

    The Deep Purple group sang “Hallelujah,” backed by agony pictures relating their phonetic mouthings with aspects of war.

    Starving Biafra to project a pop image; Vietnam horrors to titillate the viewer; Middle East bombing to sell a magazine item. Cynical and heartless.

    The dangers of watching two sets at once are obvious. You are bored and insulted, patronised, indulged and infuriated at double the rate.
    Also, you go cross-eyed.

    Mary Malone’s View, Daily Mirror, 11 Sept 1969

    Phew. We got there, just in time for me to bugger off on holiday for a week. See you soon, armchair Britain.